Explore Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

Homes for Sale in Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

Advanced Search Market Reports Home Value Connect

Welcome to your dedicated resource for Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000 in Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL. This page is your live portal for listings that match the exact homes for sale you demand, filtering out irrelevant properties to save you time. As a local Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL agent, Broker Brothers specializes in the unique market dynamics of this area, offering insights into amenities, home values, and investment potential. Start exploring the properties currently available between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000 below, or contact a local agent to discuss the details that matters most to your search.

< Back to all Homes for Sale in Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL

Search Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Price

All Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

226010365 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.

Premier Bayfront Homesite | High-Performance Vacation Rental Opportunity Exceptional opportunity to build a luxury income-producing vacation rental property on this prime bayfront homesite overlooking Estero Bay, ideally located on the highly desirable north end of Fort Myers Beach. This rare 8,525± sq ft lot (50’ x 160’) offers the potential to design an elevated luxury residence with panoramic bay views and Gulf views just across the street, creating the ultimate beach-to-bay rental destination. Perfectly positioned for the vacation market, this property offers direct boating access to Estero Bay and the Gulf of Mexico, with boating routes to Sanibel, Boca Grande, Cabbage Key, and numerous waterfront restaurants throughout Southwest Florida. The location is highly attractive to vacation guests seeking boating, beach access, and walkable island entertainment. Design a large luxury rental residence featuring multiple bedrooms, expansive outdoor living areas, rooftop or balcony viewing decks, and a resort-style pool and spa overlooking the bay. The lot offers space for outdoor entertainment areas, a private dock, and sunset-view terraces—features that significantly increase rental demand and nightly rates. An assemblage opportunity is also available with the adjacent lot at 385 Estero, creating potential for an even larger luxury rental compound or estate-sized development. Just a short walk along the beach to Times Square, the Pier District, Margaritaville, and dozens of restaurants, shops, and entertainment venues, this location consistently attracts visitors seeking the best of Fort Myers Beach. A rare investment opportunity to develop a premier waterfront vacation rental property in one of the island’s most desirable and walkable locations. Multiple Builder introductions available.

385 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

226010364 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.

Premier Coastal Luxury Bayfront Homesite | Beach-to-Bay Lifestyle. An extraordinary opportunity to build a custom Bayfront luxury estate on this exceptional homesite overlooking Estero Bay, ideally positioned on the highly coveted north end of Fort Myers Beach. This rare property offers 8,525 sq ft +/- , 50 ft x 160 ft and the potential to design an elevated residence capturing sweeping panoramic bay views with the Beaches just across the street, creating the ultimate beach-to-bay lifestyle. Perfectly situated for boating enthusiasts, the property offers direct access to Estero Bay, the Gulf and world-class destinations such as Sanibel Island, Boca Grande, Cabbage Key, and numerous waterfront restaurants nearby on Fort Myers Beach just a scenic boat ride away. Envision a stunning custom home designed to maximize the waterfront setting, with expansive terraces and outdoor living spaces perfect for enjoying vibrant sunrises over the bay and breathtaking sunsets over the Gulf. The homesite provides ample room for a resort-style pool, outdoor entertaining areas, and a private dock for effortless days on the water. Located just a short stroll along the beach to Times Square, the Pier District, Margaritaville, and a vibrant collection of restaurants, boutiques, and island entertainment, this property blends luxury waterfront living with walkable coastal charm. A rare and coveted opportunity to create a signature waterfront estate in one of Fort Myers Beach’s most prestigious and desirable locations. An ASSEMBLAGE opportunity is available with the adjacent lot at 385 ESTERO. Multiple Builder Introductions available.

355 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

2026011222 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.

Introducing an exceptional direct bayfront lot on the prestigious north end of Fort Myers Beach — an area now transforming with a collection of newly built ultra-luxury estates that are redefining the island’s skyline. This rare parcel offers a premier opportunity to design a signature residence or duplex in one of the most coveted waterfront corridors on the island. Set along the shimmering expanse of Estero Bay, the property delivers unobstructed panoramic water views, daily marine life activity, and effortless Gulf access from your future private dock. The white sands of Fort Myers Beach lie just across the street, creating a true dual-waterfront lifestyle — beach out front, boating out back. Zoned for either a single-family home or duplex and located within a short-term rental district, this lot offers exceptional flexibility for luxury living, high-end rental income, or a combination of both. With no HOA or club fees, owners retain full control over design, use, and long-term value. Surrounded by a growing enclave of multimillion-dollar custom homes, this property stands as a premier canvas for a showpiece build. Its 53-year legacy of single-family ownership underscores the rarity and desirability of this location — a place where memories have been made for decades and where a new owner can now create an extraordinary coastal retreat. A direct bayfront lot in a rapidly elevating luxury neighborhood, with beach access steps away and Gulf boating at your back door, represents one of the strongest long-term investment plays on Fort Myers Beach

507 Carlos Cir, Fort Myers Beach

2026001498 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.

Be one of the first to buy in Paradise Point on Fort Myers Beach. Located on the north end of the beach, close to Pink Shell Resort and just minutes to Time Square and Margaritaville. Easy access on and off the beach from this address. The previous Paradise Point Cottages were known for the fun and colorful cottages build in the 60's and 70's and now are being replaced with current code, elevated, hurricane resistant construction, unique and colorful custom beach houses. This is a Gulf front lot and is in the weekly rental area of the Island.

466 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

Start Your Search