Explore Homes for Sale in San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL
Map Search for San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale

San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale: Your Coastal Dream Awaits

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Discover an exquisite selection of homes for sale in San Carlos on the Gulf, a premier community nestled in Fort Myers Beach, FL.This highly sought-after area offers unparalleled access to the Gulf of Mexico, pristine beaches, and a vibrant coastal lifestyle.Prospective buyers will find diverse real estate opportunities, from charming single-family residences to luxurious waterfront estates and convenient condominiums.Whether you're seeking a permanent slice of paradise, a seasonal retreat, or a lucrative investment property, San Carlos on the Gulf presents an idyllic setting.Broker Brothers specializes in helping you navigate this competitive market to find your perfect home.

< Search all Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Search San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Lifestyle
Search San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Price
Search San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Bedrooms
Search San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Bathrooms

Exploring Homes for Sale in San Carlos on the Gulf

Prime Location and Gulf Access Homes

Searching for homes for sale in San Carlos on the Gulf means discovering properties strategically positioned for ultimate coastal convenience.This unique Fort Myers Beach community boasts exceptional access to the Gulf of Mexico, often via direct boat access from private docks or nearby marinas.Residents enjoy proximity to the pristine sands of Fort Myers Beach, ensuring countless days spent enjoying the Florida sunshine and warm Gulf waters.

What Makes San Carlos on the Gulf Unique?

Unlike some bustling areas of Fort Myers Beach, San Carlos on the Gulf offers a tranquil yet connected environment.Its charming streets, lush landscaping, and distinct community feel provide a perfect balance for those seeking peace without sacrificing access to vibrant local attractions.The selection of San Carlos on the Gulf homes for sale reflects this unique character, often featuring spacious layouts and meticulously maintained properties.

Diverse Property Types in San Carlos on the Gulf

Single-Family Homes for Sale

The majority of properties among San Carlos on the Gulf homes for sale are single-family residences, presenting a range of architectural styles from classic Florida ranch homes to elevated coastal designs engineered for resilience and views.Many feature private swimming pools, expansive lanais, and generous outdoor living spaces, perfect for entertaining or simply relaxing in your private oasis.

Waterfront Properties and Luxury Estates

For those dreaming of direct water access, the waterfront homes for sale in San Carlos on the Gulf are particularly appealing.These luxury estates often feature deep-water canals, private boat lifts, and breathtaking views, ideal for avid boaters and those who appreciate sophisticated coastal living.Properties here cater to discerning buyers seeking unparalleled amenities and prime locations.

Condominiums and Villas: Low-Maintenance Living

Beyond traditional houses, you'll also find appealing condominiums and villas, perfect for seasonal residents or those desiring a low-maintenance lifestyle.These properties often provide access to community amenities like pools, tennis courts, and fitness centers, making them excellent choices for convenient living near the best of Fort Myers Beach.

The San Carlos on the Gulf Lifestyle: More Than Just Homes

Beaches, Boating, and Outdoor Recreation

Owning one of the desirable homes for sale in San Carlos on the Gulf means embracing a lifestyle rich in outdoor activities.Beyond direct Gulf access, residents are mere minutes from Lover's Key State Park, renowned for its natural beauty, kayaking, and birdwatching.Fishing, paddleboarding, and shell collecting are daily possibilities.

Dining, Shopping, and Local Attractions

The community's convenient location ensures easy access to a variety of dining options, from casual beachfront eateries to upscale restaurants.Boutique shopping, lively entertainment, and essential services are just a short drive away, including the Santini Marina Plaza and the vibrant atmosphere of Fort Myers Beach's Times Square.The vibrant pulse of Fort Myers is also easily accessible.

Community and Investment Potential

San Carlos on the Gulf represents not just a place to live but a sound investment.Its enduring appeal for both permanent residents and vacationers ensures strong demand for Fort Myers Beach real estate.Many homeowners also utilize their properties as lucrative vacation rentals, leveraging the area's popularity to generate income.

Navigating the Fort Myers Beach Real Estate Market with Broker Brothers

Expert Guidance for Finding San Carlos on the Gulf Homes

The Fort Myers Beach real estate market, particularly for coveted areas like San Carlos on the Gulf, requires local expertise.Broker Brothers offers unparalleled insight into market trends, neighborhood nuances, and hidden gems among the available homes for sale Fort Myers Beach FL.We pride ourselves on personalized service, guiding you through every step of the process.

Long-Term Value and Market Insights

With our in-depth knowledge of San Carlos on the Gulf, Broker Brothers helps clients understand the long-term value and investment potential of properties here.We provide comprehensive market analyses and expert advice, ensuring you make informed decisions when purchasing your coastal property.Trust Broker Brothers to find your perfect home in this exceptional Fort Myers Beach community.

}

Newest Homes for Sale in San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL

$949,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 2026035905 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
Unlock incredible potential in Fort Myers Beach on San Carlos Island! Featuring Gulf & Bay sunset views and active waterway scenery, this elevated home is the ultimate canvas for a modern coastal transformation. All major structural elements are already complete: new in 2024/25 roof, HVAC, impact-resistant glass/doors, HardieBoard siding, and an updated electrical panel. Bring your interior design vision to life while capitalizing on short-term rental and a grandfathered lower-level laundry room plus living space/accessory unit partially finished and ready for personal finishes. Perfect for investors or buyers seeking an investment with income-producing potential and plenty of room for a pool! Your Island Sanctuary!

915 North St, Fort Myers Beach
$3,399,000
226031158 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Set along the bayfront of San Carlos Island, 948 San Carlos Boulevard presents an exceptional opportunity to create a custom waterfront estate on a remarkably spacious homesite. Encompassing approximately 20,830 square feet, with 100 feet of direct bay frontage and a depth of roughly 215 feet, the property offers an impressive sense of scale, privacy, and design flexibility. Western exposure provides a front-row seat to spectacular Southwest Florida sunsets, while the adjacent deep-water canal offers quick access to the Gulf of Mexico. A newer dock is already in place and designed to accommodate two boat lifts, creating immediate boating access while plans for a future residence take shape. The generous dimensions of the property allow for expansive indoor-outdoor living, substantial outdoor entertaining areas, resort-style amenities, and a residence designed to fully embrace the surrounding water views. San Carlos Island continues to evolve as an increasingly desirable waterfront destination, offering close proximity to Fort Myers Beach while maintaining convenient access on and off the island. Waterfront dining, the beaches of Fort Myers Beach, Margaritaville Resort, and local entertainment are all just minutes away, with easy connections to Sanibel, Captiva, Bonita Springs, Naples, and Southwest Florida International Airport. With no rental restrictions, the property also offers flexibility for those considering a luxury vacation residence or investment opportunity. Combining a rare half-acre setting, expansive bay frontage, deep-water Gulf access, western exposure, and an outstanding location, 948 San Carlos Boulevard is an exceptional canvas for a distinctive Southwest Florida waterfront home.

948 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$7,895,000
5 Beds ⋅ 6.5 Baths ⋅ 2026035771 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
Fort Myers Beach Gulf-Access Home for Sale - Concrete Construction on San Carlos Island, 5BR/5.5BA, 4,607 SF. Recently completed on the quiet side of San Carlos Island, on an oversized Gulf-access lot with no bridge to cross to open water. Built entirely of concrete block reinforced with rebar and filled with poured concrete, exceeding Lee County's hurricane standards, with a concrete roof, impact-resistant windows and doors, and an elevated foundation. Flood insurance policy is transferable and grandfathered in at a low rate - rare for this market. 5 bedrooms, 5 full baths, 2 half baths, 4,607 sq ft under air. Main living level is on the second floor, with a primary suite offering water views, his and hers vanities, soaking tub, large closets, and its own washer/dryer, plus a second ensuite bedroom. Three additional suites are upstairs on the third floor, each with a private bath, along with a loft and a second laundry room with extra storage. Ground floor includes a four-car garage plus a separate golf cart bay and storage. Kitchen features Monogram appliances, a butler's pantry, wine cooler, and a large island. Lanai includes drop-down hurricane screens and separate bug screens. Outdoor kitchen, Artesian lap pool with sun deck facing the Gulf, and space for a firepit. Dock includes a 38,000-lb lift for up to a 45-ft boat, a second 15,000-lb lift for a pontoon, a dedicated kayak launch, full captain's walk, and water/power at the dock. Direct Gulf access, no bridges. Direct Gulf access, no bridges. Designed by Richard Guzman, cabinetry by Ruffino, kitchen by KDL Designs. Adjacent lot is also available - ask for details.

938 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$1,999,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026008594 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
Coming 2026, White Sands and Sea Glass are elevated coastal residences in the prestigious San Carlos on the Gulf neighborhood of Fort Myers Beach, positioned among luxury homes and removed from the congestion of the main beach district. Featuring expansive open-concept living, oversized rooms, and refined coastal finishes, the elevated main level captures natural light and enhanced views. Built to current hurricane standards with elevator rough-in and optional pool, this is sophisticated island living offering comfort, privacy, and long-term coastal value, all within walking distance to beaches, marina’s, and waterfront dining. Pre-construction opportunity; pricing may evolve as construction progresses.

961 San Carlos Ct, Fort Myers Beach
$4,200,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 2026002641 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
This is the Fort Myers Beach property that truly has it all—bayfront luxury with Gulf views, oversized grounds, income potential, and resort-style amenities. With 7 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, and an elevator, this exceptional estate is designed for both comfort and convenience, offered fully turnkey. The main residence rises three levels above a private apartment that opens directly to the heated pool and jacuzzi. Multiple balconies and screened decks capture long water views, while the top-level bedroom lookout provides a panoramic perspective of both Estero Bay and the Gulf of America. A wood-burning fireplace adds warmth and character to the spacious living areas. A separate guest house with its own garage sits at the front of the property and is currently leased to a long-term tenant, delivering a proven consistent annual rental income. The main home also offers excellent rental income, making this both a lifestyle retreat and a smart investment. Boaters will appreciate the private dock, complete with a captain’s walk and a 10,000 lb. boat lift—ideal for quick access to open water. The oversized lot enhances the estate feel, providing rare space and privacy on Fort Myers Beach. Perfectly located to avoid the heavy beach traffic yet just minutes from the shoreline, dining, and entertainment, this property offers the best of island living. With unmatched views, exceptional amenities, and turnkey convenience, this is one of the most remarkable opportunities on Fort Myers Beach.

950 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$5,485,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6.5 Baths ⋅ 225082699 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
This is 793 San Carlos Drive—less a house and more a waypoint on the map of a life well-lived. A modern coastal refuge tucked into the salty heartbeat of Fort Myers Beach, where the air smells of sunburnt afternoons and the tide keeps its own kind of time. Built the right way—block and steel from the ground all the way up to the roof. Perfectly positioned for those grand, cinematic sunsets that spill across Matanzas Bay, the kind you watch in silence because words just get in the way. Built for poolside barbeques that run late, for Florida winter nights when conversation drifts like smoke, for slow bike rides to seafood joints where the fish are still telling stories from the Gulf. Inside, two primary suites and four guest rooms, all en-suite, make it the sort of place where family converges, friends linger, and nobody feels like they drew the short straw. It’s a home that doesn’t just host memories; it cooks them slowly, like something that gets better the longer you let it simmer. The kitchen is the soul of it all. Mid-century esque meets modern, a space begging for simple ingredients, good knives, and better company. From here, you can watch the world wander by on the water while you stir, chop, taste, and exist—exactly as you are. From the terrace, the view opens in soft, deliberate layers—first across untouched Grayson Island and its protected bird sanctuary, then out toward the distant shimmer of Fort Myers Beach’s skyline, with the Sanibel Causeway stretching quietly along the eastern edge of the horizon. Up top, the dual primary suites hide away like little sanctuaries, each with wide-open views that remind you why people chase the horizon in the first place. Everything inside has been curated with a sharp, contemporary eye—furnishings that feel effortless, textures that feel intentional. It’s the kind of place you can step into and immediately exhale. Turn the key, and you’re already living the life. With Control4 automation, hidden surround sound, a Tesla charger, Generac generator and a build engineered to shrug off coastal moods, this home blends luxury with durability. A place made for people who appreciate beauty—but also know that the world is imperfect, unpredictable, and worth experiencing anyway. The water keeps its rhythm. The sunsets write their own script. All that’s missing is someone to call it home. Perhaps that’s you. Schedule a showing today.

793 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$1,999,000
225070841 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
60 Feet of Waterfront Views – A Bayfront Jewel on San Carlos Island! Waterfront royalty awaits on this rare, 60-foot stretch of bayfront paradise—perfectly positioned with no-bridge boating to the Gulf in just five minutes. This extraordinary property offers a blank canvas for creating a single-family estate or even a stunning duplex worthy of its setting. An optional adjacent parcel (922) MLS #225070838 is also available if you desire a larger estate. Builder referrals are on hand, giving you even more opportunity to bring your vision to life. Spend your days boating to a dozen nearby restaurants for lunch or dinner, or simply savor serene sunsets over the bay from your own backyard. Located a short stroll from the pristine, sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach—yet away from the bustle of heavy traffic—this San Carlos Island address combines true island living with the convenience of Lee County’s streamlined building process. Rarely do opportunities of this caliber present themselves. Here, you can design and build a residence that captures the very best of bayfront living, offering privacy, beauty, and the quintessential Southwest Florida lifestyle.

926 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$2,099,000
225070838 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
Bayfront Bliss Meets Coastal Adventure – 60 Feet of Waterfront Views - A Lot Like No Other! Unmatched opportunity awaits with this extraordinary Bayfront/Gulf-access property on San Carlos Island. Offering 60 Feet of Panoramic Waterfront Views and effortless access to the Gulf with no-bridge boating in just five minutes. This rare lot provides a pristine canvas for crafting a spectacular single-family estate or an impressive duplex that celebrates Southwest Florida’s coastal lifestyle. The adjacent parcel (926) MLS #225070841 is also available if you desire a larger footprint or wish to create an expansive dream estate. Builder referrals are on hand, giving you even more opportunity to bring your vision to life. Savor breathtaking sunsets and watch a lively parade of boats from your own backyard, or head out to some of the region’s best fishing grounds. With dozens of waterfront restaurants just a short boat ride away, every outing becomes an adventure. Perfectly positioned within walking distance of the sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach—yet tucked away from the bustle of heavy traffic—this San Carlos Island address combines true island living with the convenience of Lee County’s streamlined permitting and building process. Opportunities of this caliber are exceptionally rare, offering the freedom to design a home that captures the very best of bayfront living and the relaxed, vibrant spirit of Southwest Florida.

922 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$348,000
225022295 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
Be part of the revitalizatioon of Fort Myers Beach on San Carlos Island. This fabulous deep water lot with gulf access and no bridges to Estero Bay and the Gulf. Seawall redone in last five years. Lot cleared an ready for your new home. Builder introductions available. New development planned directly behind to include a New Marina, condos/hotel and more....jump on the Key West express or dine at Parrot Key. Walk or bike right over the bridge to Fort Myers Beach downtown area and Margaritaville. Great location.

829 Oak St, Fort Myers Beach
$569,000
225022280 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
Location, location, location . . . this well-priced commercial parcel is located off San Carlos Drive just this side of the bridge It's within walking or biking distance from our beautiful sandy beaches, and surrounded by fine dining like Doc Ford's and Dixie Fish House. Property is zoned C-1. Located behind Diversified Yacht Services with million dollar homes across the street on the Bay.

752 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$524,900
223019019 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
These motivated Seller’s just reduced the price over 50K! Now is your opportunity to build your dream home on this prime, Ft. Myers Beach Lot. Enjoy a bike ride, stroll or take your golf cart to local restaurants and shops, while catching the breathtaking sunsets of San Carlos Island. This lot is completely cleared and ready to build. Come and be a part of the revitalization of the vibrant island community of Fort Myers Beach. You have found your very own 'Peace' of Paradise!

947 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
Start Your Search