Explore San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Over $3,500,000

San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Over $3,500,000 Map Search

Homes for Sale in San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL Over $3,500,000

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Welcome to your dedicated resource for Homes for Sale Over $3,500,000 in San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL. This page is your live portal for listings that match the exact homes for sale you demand, filtering out irrelevant properties to save you time. As a local San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL agent, Broker Brothers specializes in the unique market dynamics of this area, offering insights into amenities, home values, and investment potential. Start exploring the properties currently available over $3,500,000 below, or contact a local agent to discuss the details that matters most to your search.

< Back to all Homes for Sale in San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL

Search San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Price

All San Carlos on the Gulf, Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Over $3,500,000

841 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$6,250,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5.5 Baths ⋅ 226034777 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
A rare waterfront masterpiece, this spectacular custom bayfront residence delivers breathtaking panoramic views, direct Gulf access, and an extraordinary level of luxury—offering the ultimate Southwest Florida waterfront lifestyle. Designed to capture the beauty of its spectacular setting, this 4-bedroom, 4 full and 2 half-bath home combines sophisticated design with incredible indoor/outdoor living. The light filled open floor plan showcases soaring ceilings, oversized tile and hardwood flooring, a dramatic custom glass staircase and walls of glass framing panoramic water views. The gourmet kitchen is a showpiece with premium Viking appliances, built-in coffee maker, expansive island and abundant space for entertaining. The luxurious primary suite features its own private balcony overlooking the bay and an impressive spa-inspired bath. Outside is where the Florida lifestyle truly shines! Enjoy a resort-style pool and spa, expansive outdoor living area with built-in bar and grill, and spectacular sunset views across the water. A newly added artificial-turf putting green sits directly along the seawall, creating an incredible waterfront setting to practice your short game. Boaters will appreciate direct Gulf access and an impressive dock featuring a 32,000-lb platform boat lift plus an additional lift for another boat or water toys. Additional upgrades include a whole-house generator and flood barrier protection for added peace of mind. And for something truly extraordinary—this home even features its own private indoor pickleball court! Elevator in foyer for those that wish to skip the stairs! Ideally located near Fort Myers Beach, this one-of-a-kind bayfront residence delivers the complete Southwest Florida lifestyle—luxury, boating, entertaining, recreation and unforgettable waterfront sunsets, all from your own private paradise.

841 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
938 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$7,895,000
5 Beds ⋅ 6.5 Baths ⋅ 2026035771 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
Fort Myers Beach Gulf-Access Home for Sale - Concrete Construction on San Carlos Island, 5BR/5.5BA, 4,607 SF. Recently completed on the quiet side of San Carlos Island, on an oversized Gulf-access lot with no bridge to cross to open water. Built entirely of concrete block reinforced with rebar and filled with poured concrete, exceeding Lee County's hurricane standards, with a concrete roof, impact-resistant windows and doors, and an elevated foundation. Flood insurance policy is transferable and grandfathered in at a low rate - rare for this market. 5 bedrooms, 5 full baths, 2 half baths, 4,607 sq ft under air. Main living level is on the second floor, with a primary suite offering water views, his and hers vanities, soaking tub, large closets, and its own washer/dryer, plus a second ensuite bedroom. Three additional suites are upstairs on the third floor, each with a private bath, along with a loft and a second laundry room with extra storage. Ground floor includes a four-car garage plus a separate golf cart bay and storage. Kitchen features Monogram appliances, a butler's pantry, wine cooler, and a large island. Lanai includes drop-down hurricane screens and separate bug screens. Outdoor kitchen, Artesian lap pool with sun deck facing the Gulf, and space for a firepit. Dock includes a 38,000-lb lift for up to a 45-ft boat, a second 15,000-lb lift for a pontoon, a dedicated kayak launch, full captain's walk, and water/power at the dock. Direct Gulf access, no bridges. Direct Gulf access, no bridges. Designed by Richard Guzman, cabinetry by Ruffino, kitchen by KDL Designs. Adjacent lot is also available - ask for details.

938 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
793 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$5,485,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6.5 Baths ⋅ 225082699 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
This is 793 San Carlos Drive—less a house and more a waypoint on the map of a life well-lived. A modern coastal refuge tucked into the salty heartbeat of Fort Myers Beach, where the air smells of sunburnt afternoons and the tide keeps its own kind of time. Built the right way—block and steel from the ground all the way up to the roof. Perfectly positioned for those grand, cinematic sunsets that spill across Matanzas Bay, the kind you watch in silence because words just get in the way. Built for poolside barbeques that run late, for Florida winter nights when conversation drifts like smoke, for slow bike rides to seafood joints where the fish are still telling stories from the Gulf. Inside, two primary suites and four guest rooms, all en-suite, make it the sort of place where family converges, friends linger, and nobody feels like they drew the short straw. It’s a home that doesn’t just host memories; it cooks them slowly, like something that gets better the longer you let it simmer. The kitchen is the soul of it all. Mid-century esque meets modern, a space begging for simple ingredients, good knives, and better company. From here, you can watch the world wander by on the water while you stir, chop, taste, and exist—exactly as you are. From the terrace, the view opens in soft, deliberate layers—first across untouched Grayson Island and its protected bird sanctuary, then out toward the distant shimmer of Fort Myers Beach’s skyline, with the Sanibel Causeway stretching quietly along the eastern edge of the horizon. Up top, the dual primary suites hide away like little sanctuaries, each with wide-open views that remind you why people chase the horizon in the first place. Everything inside has been curated with a sharp, contemporary eye—furnishings that feel effortless, textures that feel intentional. It’s the kind of place you can step into and immediately exhale. Turn the key, and you’re already living the life. With Control4 automation, hidden surround sound, a Tesla charger, Generac generator and a build engineered to shrug off coastal moods, this home blends luxury with durability. A place made for people who appreciate beauty—but also know that the world is imperfect, unpredictable, and worth experiencing anyway. The water keeps its rhythm. The sunsets write their own script. All that’s missing is someone to call it home. Perhaps that’s you. Schedule a showing today.

793 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!