Sanibel, FL Real Estate Search

Sanibel, FL Recently Sold Homes

Our website features the best real estate search for recently sold homes in Sanibel, FL and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Sanibel, FL real estate market? Sign up for a  Sanibel, FL Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Sanibel, FL Recently Sold Homes for Sale

$1,270,000
3 Beds 2.5 Baths 224095259 MLS Metes And Bounds BLDG.
This meticulously maintained property has been thoughtfully upgraded over the years with significant investments in durability, efficiency & style. Major enhancements include a complete kitchen remodel featuring all-new appliances and the renovation of all bathrooms to reflect a modern & sophisticated design. High-impact windows, framed with Hardie Board trim to prevent rot, offer durability. The home’s infrastructure has been further enhanced with the replacement of all water pipes throughout the house, a new air conditioning unit, & a new water heater. The garage has also been updated with a sleek, epoxy-coated floor. Outdoor living is a dream with a resurfaced pool, new pool deck, heater, & pump, along with a rescreened pool cage. The Trex back deck and stairs provide a low-maintenance solution for enjoying the island’s natural beauty, while the paver driveway adds to the home’s curb appeal. The lower level was stuccoed and painted in 2022, with the addition of air conditioning to the garage and workout room for added comfort. Perfectly situated on Sanibel’s desirable East Gulf Drive, this home includes deeded beach access and is close to local shops, and restaurants. With every major system and surface thoughtfully updated, this property is ready for years of enjoyment. Don’t miss this opportunity to own a beautifully upgraded home in one of Southwest Florida’s most sought-after locations. Schedule your private showing today!

345 E Gulf Dr, Sanibel

$725,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224083028 MLS Del Sega BLDG.
SELLER SAYS BRING OFFERS! POOL IS IN PERFECT WORKING CONDITION, EQUIPMENT IS ELEVATED. NEW KITCHEN CABINETS ARE IN PLACE AND READY TO BE INSTALLED. Time for you to act now and create your Sanibel Island retreat! This beach house has so much character and charm- the A-Frame design brings in the light and the shiplap white pine ceiling are truly unique. The centerpiece of the living area is a beautiful fireplace. Expansive kitchen with a large island and separate wet bar/ prep area. The Primary Bedroom is graced with high shiplap beamed ceilings, 2 large closets and a large en suite complete with soaking tub, separate custom glass enclosed shower. The two spacious guest rooms also feature generous closets and high ceilings. The separate detached two-car garage and office area provide convenience and functionality. Last but not least take a dip in the pool (after cleaning) surrounded by lush tropical vegetation. This Beach Cottage has so many unique and special features, it has even been featured in Times of the Island magazine, showcasing its timeless appeal. Exterior Hardi Board Siding and Trim, Trex decking. Located on Sanibel Island, steps to the world famous pristine beaches and stunning sunsets, Live the island life and make this charming retreat your own. This property sustained minor damage from hurricane Milton, all photos were taken pre storm, all plank flooring, Lower kitchen cabinets and appliances have been removed, BUT NEW LOWER CABINETS ARE IN PLACE AND READY FOR YOU TO INSTALL -it has been remediated and awaits your vision.

2604 Coconut Dr, Sanibel

$804,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224093422 MLS Caloosa Shores BLDG.
One of the hidden gems on Sanibel is Caloosa Shores, a residential community encircled by tidal bays and thousands of acres of wildlife sanctuary lands, a heaven on earth for anyone who appreciates the type of tranquility you can only find living among nature. If the best parcels on the island were developed first, it speaks to how special this location is in terms of the unspoiled natural beauty of the land around you and the deep water, direct access boating right outside your door. The original CBS, slab-on-grade structure was mitigated and deep cleaned, preserving the durable, undamaged construction materials for reuse if desired. Priced at land value, this property offers a multitude of options such as restoring as is, elevating or building new. If a buyer is interested in lifting the home, we have estimates to elevate the home 5 feet approximately $145,000, build the infrastructure for the elevated home such as utilities, concrete block piles and stairs approximately $150,000, and to restore the interior. We also have estimates for demolition and construction of a new luxury modular home, and we are working on estimates for installation of floodproof gates. Boating amenities include a kayak launch, boat dock with composite decking and boat lift on a saltwater gulf access canal. Dock and lift added by Stokes Marine in 2021. Built in 2021 by Coastal Custom Pools, the expansive pool surrounded by natural stone pavers runs the length of the house, flanked on one end by an elevated spillover spa. After adding a new roof in 2020, the home was equipped with high-quality solar panels with capacity to provide more than enough electrical power for the home. If desired battery storage packs can be added taking the home completely off the grid or acting as a backup generator in event of an emergency. Please note there was a $33,520 special assessment for the Caloosa Shores bridge construction, buyer to assume remaining $16k+/-.

5297 Punta Caloosa Ct, Sanibel

$2,150,000
4 Beds 6.5 Baths 224046392 MLS The Sanctuary BLDG.
JUST REDUCED 9/7! THE BEST INVESTOR OR HOME OWNER OPPORTUNITY ON THE ISLAND! In the Sanctuary on Sanibel's west end. As you approach the home on the corner of Wulfert Road & Troon CT., you're greeted by its impressive façade and a .63 acre lot. This is the largest available home & NOTHING COMPARES! Listed way UNDER APPRAISAL! NEW steel-coated metal ROOF and all new mechanicals throughout. Step inside to discover marble and tile flooring leading your eyes directly to the great outdoors. Linger inside and enjoy the cathedral ceiling with statement chandelier. A cozy fireplace and generous seating area can accommodate large parties and guests. FOUR ensuite bedrooms, 5 full and 2 half baths, provide privacy and convenience to family and guests. For outdoor enthusiasts, there is a full bath thoughtfully located off the pool and BBQ area. The 1st FLOOR PRIMARY bedroom overlooks the resort-worthy pool + golf course and is beautifully appointed with 2 private bathrooms, and 2 large closets. The beautiful den/office/sitting room is fabulous in its own right. It will end up being one of your favorite rooms in the house. Architectural details in the crown + dentil mouldings and frieze highlight this area. A gas fireplace will warm you when needed on those cool nights. The heart of the home is the GOURMET KITCHEN, directly off the large great room, with top-of-the-line appliances, quartz counters, custom cabinetry, breakfast bar, beverage refrigerators, 2 microwaves, 2 ovens, cooktop and a generous island that’s perfect for casual dining + entertaining. Right off the kitchen is the wet bar area. The formal dining room boasts cathedral height ceilings + large windows. Dentil moulding and frieze are some of the unique features in this dining area, with built-in storage. Nearby are laundry facilities and private elevator access to the three 2nd floor ensuite bedrooms. For those who love the outdoors, the 2-story screened-in lanai is easily accessed from the living areas. The resort-style pool and spa has a swim-up bar, creating a fun place to hang out. The BBQ area makes it an ideal spot for gatherings. The expansive property includes a versatile BONUS ROOM above the detached 2-car garage, perfect for a fitness/media/games/office/bunk room/apartment. There are two 2-car garages for a total of 4 CAR GARAGE + GOLF CART EXIT. Detached garage has elevator to the 2nd floor. This extraordinary home has the perfect combination of luxury, a prime location, and the added benefit of being just steps away from world-class golfing. Hit the links quickly, with a golf cart access door in the attached 2 car garage. There are Sanctuary Club and social memberships are available. All amenities you would expect are offered here at The Club. Just minutes to the Gulf of Mexico. Enjoy boating, world-class fishing or just spending the day enjoying the aquamarine waters and white sandy beaches. DON'T JUST DREAM THE LIFE.....LIVE THE DREAM! WELCOME TO YOUR NEW HOME! SELLER MOTIVATED!

2255 Troon Ct, Sanibel

$4,200,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 223076243 MLS Gulf Shores BLDG.
Experience the epitome of island living with this stunning Sanibel beachfront home! Meticulously renovated to accentuate space and capture the essence of Sanibel's beauty, this architectural masterpiece offers unparalleled luxury. Savor awe-inspiring 180-degree views of the Gulf of Mexico from your own Gulf Front retreat, a location that's truly one-of-a-kind. Every detail of this home has been thoughtfully designed, with no expense spared. From the brand-new HVAC, electric, and plumbing to the impact skylights and windows/doors, every aspect exudes quality and craftsmanship. Step inside to discover luxury vinyl wood-like floating floors, designer tiles, and an enviable kitchen featuring top-of-the-line Thermador appliances, custom cabinetry, and designer wallpapers. With four bedrooms, four baths, and two laundry areas, this home offers ample space for family and guests. Enjoy cozy evenings by the electric fireplace or entertain in style in the open gallery living area, where a Nana-wall seamlessly connects indoor and outdoor living spaces. Professionally designed landscaping by Coastal Vista surrounds the property, creating a serene oasis just steps from the private beach path. Additional features include a double-car garage and upscale finishes throughout. Sold fully furnished with beautifully appointed pieces from Sanibel Home Furnishings, this home is truly a premiere showcase of island living. Seize the opportunity to immerse yourself in unparalleled luxury and serenity – schedule your private viewing today!

4577 Waters Edge Ln, Sanibel

Start Your Search