Explore Homes for Sale in Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL
Map Search for Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale

Island Shores Homes for Sale: Your Fort Myers Beach Paradise Awaits

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Discover an exquisite selection of Island Shores homes for sale in picturesque Fort Myers Beach, Florida. This exclusive waterfront community offers a unique blend of luxury, convenience, and stunning Gulf access. Prospective buyers will find a diverse array of properties, from charming canal-front cottages to expansive custom estates, perfect for embracing the quintessential Southwest Florida lifestyle. Explore current listings and uncover your dream property within this sought-after enclave. Broker Brothers is your trusted partner for navigating the dynamic Island Shores real estate market, helping you find the perfect home that reflects your vision of coastal living.

< Search all Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Search Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Lifestyle
Search Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Price
Search Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Bedrooms
Search Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL by Bathrooms

Exploring Island Shores Homes for Sale: A Premier Fort Myers Beach Destination

Island Shores, nestled within the vibrant landscape of Fort Myers Beach, presents an unparalleled opportunity for those seeking exceptional homes for sale. This highly desirable neighborhood is renowned for its idyllic setting, offering residents direct access to the Gulf of Mexico via its intricate canal system. The allure of Island Shores lies not just in its prime location but also in the quality and diversity of its residential offerings. Many properties here boast private docks, catering to boating enthusiasts who value convenience and immediate access to open water. As you consider homes for sale in this coveted area, you're not just buying a property; you're investing in a lifestyle defined by sun-drenched days, aquatic adventures, and breathtaking sunsets.

Types of Homes for Sale in Island Shores

The real estate landscape in Island Shores is rich and varied, providing options to suit a wide range of preferences and budgets. You'll find a splendid mix of architectural styles and property types among the available homes for sale. From elegant single-family residences to spacious multi-story estates, each property contributes to the community's unique charm.

  • Waterfront Residences: The quintessential Island Shores experience often involves a waterfront home. These properties frequently feature private boat lifts, expansive lanais, and stunning views of the canals or surrounding natural beauty. For those searching for canal-front homes for sale, Island Shores is a prime location.

  • Luxurious Estates: Expect to find custom-built homes with high-end finishes, gourmet kitchens, private pools, and sophisticated design elements. These larger homes for sale often cater to buyers seeking a permanent residence or a grand vacation retreat.

  • Charming Coastal Cottages: For a more intimate Fort Myers Beach experience, some charming, updated cottages offer a perfect blend of comfort and convenience, ideal for seasonal residents or smaller families.

The Island Shores Lifestyle: More Than Just Homes for Sale

Choosing Island Shores means embracing a lifestyle deeply intertwined with the natural beauty and recreational opportunities of Fort Myers Beach. The community itself fosters a serene environment while remaining close to all the action. When exploring homes for sale here, prospective residents often envision days spent on the water, whether it's fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, or simply cruising the Gulf.

Proximity to Fort Myers Beach Amenities

One of the significant advantages of considering Island Shores homes for sale is the convenient access to local attractions and amenities. Residents are just a short drive or bike ride away from the pristine white sands of Fort Myers Beach, where they can enjoy swimming, sunbathing, and shell collecting. The vibrant Times Square area, with its array of restaurants, shops, and entertainment options, is also easily reachable. Additionally, the Santini Marina is nearby for those needing additional marine services.

Community and Recreation

Island Shores offers a welcoming atmosphere, making it a wonderful place to call home. Many residents enjoy evening strolls along the tree-lined streets, taking in the picturesque surroundings. The community's strategic location also provides easy access to local golf courses, nature preserves like Lovers Key State Park, and a variety of dining experiences ranging from casual beachside cafes to upscale waterfront restaurants. These elements combine to create a compelling argument for exploring the current homes for sale in Island Shores.

Navigating the Island Shores Real Estate Market with Broker Brothers

The Fort Myers Beach real estate market, particularly within exclusive communities like Island Shores, can be dynamic. When seeking exceptional Island Shores homes for sale, partnering with a knowledgeable local expert is crucial. Broker Brothers brings unparalleled local insight and a commitment to understanding your specific needs.

Your Partner for Finding Island Shores Homes for Sale

Whether you are searching for a luxurious waterfront estate, a charming canal-front home, or a peaceful seasonal retreat, Broker Brothers is dedicated to guiding you through every step of the process. We pride ourselves on providing personalized service, up-to-date market information, and a seamless buying experience. Let us assist you in discovering the ideal property among the diverse selection of homes for sale in Island Shores, ensuring your investment aligns perfectly with your lifestyle aspirations in Fort Myers Beach.

Newest Homes for Sale in Island Shores, Fort Myers Beach, FL

$6,000,000
2026019063 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
Rare opportunity to own a prime beachfront development site on beautiful Fort Myers Beach! This unique offering includes two adjoining lots being sold together, boasting approximately 105+/- feet of direct Gulf frontage and endless possibilities for investors, developers, or those seeking an exceptional coastal property. The combined parcels are approved to accommodate up to five cottages, with five water hookups already in place, adding tremendous value and convenience for future development. Ideally situated next door to the Best Western Plus Beach Resort, with residential property on the opposite side, this location provides the perfect blend of accessibility, neighboring amenities, and privacy. Enjoy all that Fort Myers Beach has to offer, including waterfront dining, boutique shopping, boating, swimming, sunbathing, and vibrant entertainment. Just moments away is the popular Margaritaville resort destination, making this property even more desirable. Whether you're looking to build income producing vacation cottages, a private beachfront retreat, or capitalize on one of Southwest Florida’s most sought after beach communities, this is an exceptional opportunity to invest in paradise. Strap #'s for both lots are 24-46-23-W4-00400.013A (approx .55 acres) & 24-46-23-W4-00400.013D (approx .33acres)

650 & 632 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$990,000
226017061 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Exceptional Gulf-view lot located on the highly desirable north end of Fort Myers Beach. Potential Gross Income $200,000++ in a NEW 5-6 Bedroom New Construction home that can be built on the lot. Located in one of the area’s top-performing short-term rental zones. Just a short walk across the street to direct beach access, this prime location also places you near Margaritaville and the vibrant Times Square district, offering dining, entertainment, and attractions guests love. Build your dream elevated coastal home with 5+ bedrooms and a resort-style pool, perfectly designed to maximize rental appeal and income potential. This area is known for strong occupancy and premium rental rates, with similar 5-bedroom short-term rentals generating potential gross income of $200,000+ annually. A rare opportunity to create a high-income producing beach retreat in one of Southwest Florida’s most sought-after vacation destinations.

521 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$1,150,000
226013064 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
Discover the perfect canvas for your island dream home on the sugar-white sands of Fort Myers Beach. This 50x120 Gulf-side vacant lot offers an exceptional opportunity to build a custom coastal retreat tailored to your vision—whether it’s a luxurious personal getaway or a high-performing investment property. Ideally positioned in a weekly rental zone, this property presents outstanding income potential with strong demand for short-term beach rentals. Just a short stroll from the vibrant energy of Times Square, you’ll enjoy effortless access to popular dining, shopping, and entertainment, along with the highly anticipated new pier that will further enhance the area’s appeal. The neighboring home in front is only one story, creating a rare advantage—build a two-story residence with an inverted floor plan and unlock sweeping, panoramic Gulf views from your main living and entertaining spaces. Imagine sunset vistas, sea breezes, and indoor-outdoor living designed to maximize the beauty of your surroundings. Whether you’re envisioning a serene coastal escape or a lucrative beachside investment, this prime homesite delivers location, flexibility, and limitless potential in one of Southwest Florida’s most desirable destinations. Multiple builder introductions and plans are available, not included in purchase price.

626 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,699,000
2026011222 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
Introducing an exceptional direct bayfront lot on the prestigious north end of Fort Myers Beach — an area now transforming with a collection of newly built ultra-luxury estates that are redefining the island’s skyline. This rare parcel offers a premier opportunity to design a signature residence or duplex in one of the most coveted waterfront corridors on the island. Set along the shimmering expanse of Estero Bay, the property delivers unobstructed panoramic water views, daily marine life activity, and effortless Gulf access from your future private dock. The white sands of Fort Myers Beach lie just across the street, creating a true dual-waterfront lifestyle — beach out front, boating out back. Zoned for either a single-family home or duplex and located within a short-term rental district, this lot offers exceptional flexibility for luxury living, high-end rental income, or a combination of both. With no HOA or club fees, owners retain full control over design, use, and long-term value. Surrounded by a growing enclave of multimillion-dollar custom homes, this property stands as a premier canvas for a showpiece build. Its 53-year legacy of single-family ownership underscores the rarity and desirability of this location — a place where memories have been made for decades and where a new owner can now create an extraordinary coastal retreat. A direct bayfront lot in a rapidly elevating luxury neighborhood, with beach access steps away and Gulf boating at your back door, represents one of the strongest long-term investment plays on Fort Myers Beach

507 Carlos Cir, Fort Myers Beach
$1,899,000
226006185 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. SHOVEL-READY Gulf Access development opportunity in the heart of Fort Myers Beach. One of the only vacant lots on the island offering approved architectural plans, engineering, and development work already completed—allowing a buyer to bypass much of the time, uncertainty, and expense typically associated with waterfront development. Situated on a rare oversized 0.40-acre (17,293 sq. ft.) Gulf-access canal-front homesite directly across from the beach, this property offers exceptional flexibility for investors, developers, or end users seeking a premier waterfront location. Approved plans are in place for a luxury triplex designed to capitalize on both bay views and the property’s outstanding income-producing potential. Located just north of Times Square and the Pier District, owners and guests can enjoy a highly walkable lifestyle with immediate access to the beach, waterfront dining, entertainment, shopping, Margaritaville, and the island’s most desirable attractions. Boaters will appreciate quick Gulf access, while beach lovers will enjoy spectacular sunsets just steps away. With development plans already established and significant pre-construction work completed, this property represents a rare opportunity to move forward far faster than most vacant lots currently available on Fort Myers Beach. Whether your vision is a luxury investment property, multi-generational retreat, or income-producing waterfront development, this homesite combines location, boating access, beach proximity, and development readiness in a way that is increasingly difficult to find. Multiple builder introductions available. Approved plans and development information available upon request.

601 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$1,595,000
2025015697 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
Price just reduced! Discover one of the most desirable bayfront opportunities near Bowditch Point Park on the far north end of Fort Myers Beach. This property offers wide views of the Bay, and the beach is just across the street with an easy walk to the vibrant Times Square district, where restaurants, pubs and entertainment abound. Boaters will appreciate the quick access to the open Gulf Waters. Located in a weekly rental zone, this property also presents a valuable investment opportunity for owners interested in generating income through a rental program once a home is built. With its rare combination of bayfront tranquility, Gulf proximity, walkability, and panoramic views, this property stands out as one of the most exceptional waterfront offerings on Fort Myers Beach. A perfect canvas for your dream coastal home.

475 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$950,000
2026001292 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
BEACH SIDE WITH BEACH ACCESS ! Build your dream cottage here ! North end old cottage lot ! Bay views and beach views , dead end to the Gulf ! This is a weekly rental area so maximize your investment by renting it out and make an income ! This is a dead end , legal access street to the Gulf off America , not a paved street but a Sandy street like access so other cottages have access as well! Steps in the white soft sand take you to the gulf in minutes. Build a modular , or stick build up off the ground with parking underneath and storage! There are some going up now nearby so you can see both! Electric, water, sewage are already for you to plug into! Don’t wait this won’t last !

700 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,750,000
2026001498 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
Be one of the first to buy in Paradise Point on Fort Myers Beach. Located on the north end of the beach, close to Pink Shell Resort and just minutes to Time Square and Margaritaville. Easy access on and off the beach from this address. The previous Paradise Point Cottages were known for the fun and colorful cottages build in the 60's and 70's and now are being replaced with current code, elevated, hurricane resistant construction, unique and colorful custom beach houses. This is a Gulf front lot and is in the weekly rental area of the Island.

466 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$795,000
2025023356 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
Fantastic opportunity to build your dream BEACH cottage on the GULFSIDE of Estero BLVD in a premier North End location on Fort Myers Beach with WEEKLY rentals! This prime lot offers direct beach access, stunning Gulf views, & unforgettable sunsets right outside your door. The location truly can’t be beat with everything you need to enjoy the best of island living just a short distance away. From Times Square, The Pier, Margaritaville, Pink Shell, to Downtown, you're just steps from vibrant waterfront dining, live music, bars, boutiques, farmers markets & so much more. The newly approved Arches Bayfront redevelopment will bring even more exciting amenities to your neighborhood. Positioned perfectly for easy access on and off the island, this location helps you avoid most of the traffic and makes venturing inland a breeze. The 50x60ft Gulfside lot is a blank canvas ready for your vision whether you're building your ideal beach getaway, a seasonal retreat, or a high-demand investment property this is where you want to be. Approved plans, renderings, survey, and MUD are available upon request. Don’t miss this awesome opportunity to be part of the renaissance and revitalization of Fort Myers Beach & start living the Southwest Florida lifestyle today! Call Today!

612 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$1,149,000
223002938 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
Prime Canal Front Opportunity — Build Your Island Dream Buyers, builders, and developers — this exceptional canal front lot is ready for your vision. Positioned on an 80-foot wide, deepwater canal with direct Gulf access and no bridges, this property is ideal for both deep draft sailboats and powerboats. With a seawall already in place, the groundwork is set for your custom retreat or a high demand investment property. Just step across the street, enjoy the sandy Gulf shoreline and the chance to witness the legendary Green Flash at sunset. Located on the desirable north end of the island, this lot offers the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience — easy on/off access by car, yet walkable to shopping, dining, entertainment; Bowditch Point Park, Times Square, and Margaritaville. Endless boating, fishing, beach days, and unforgettable sunsets await. Bring your imagination and create the coastal lifestyle you’ve always wanted.

587 Carlos Circle, Fort Myers Beach
Start Your Search