Explore Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $1,500,000 to $2,500,000

Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $1,500,000 to $2,500,000 Map Search

Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL Between $1,500,000 to $2,500,000

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Welcome to your dedicated resource for Homes for Sale Between $1,500,000 to $2,500,000 in Fort Myers Beach, FL. This page is your live portal for listings that match the exact homes for sale you demand, filtering out irrelevant properties to save you time. As a local Fort Myers Beach, FL agent, Broker Brothers specializes in the unique market dynamics of this area, offering insights into amenities, home values, and investment potential. Start exploring the properties currently available between $1,500,000 to $2,500,000 below, or contact a local agent to discuss the details that matters most to your search.

< Back to all Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Search Fort Myers Beach, FL by Price

All Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $1,500,000 to $2,500,000

$2,095,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 225083535 MLS ⋅ Waterside At Bay Beach BLDG.
IMMEDIATE OCCUPANCY! One of London Bay's remaining furnished residences in the newest and final tower in the gated community of Waterside at Bay Beach Lane. The wait is over for new construction on Fort Myers Beach/Estero Island, Florida's "Gold Coast". Enjoy this limited opportunity to be part of Grandview at Bay Beach, on the southern tip of Estero Island, just a stone's throw from Lover's Key, nestled between Fort Myers & Bonita Springs/Naples, where days begin with glorious sunrises, are spent leisurely shelling, beaching and boating, and end with amazing sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico. Grandview at Bay Beach is the ONLY new construction tower with WALKABILITY to the beach. Grandview is within walking distance to shopping, restaurants, a full-service marina, and in close proximity to RSW airport. This is truly a unique opportunity with limited residences available! Welcome to elevated waterfront living on Estero Island at Grandview. CONTACT US TODAY FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF REMAINING RESIDENCES!

4142 Bay Beach Ln Unit 306, Fort Myers Beach
$2,195,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2025023503 MLS ⋅ Gateway Villas BLDG.
Welcome to Gateway Villas at DaBeach on Estero Island—perfectly positioned along the highly sought-after north end of Fort Myers Beach. Nestled on the pristine one-mile stretch of sand between Times Square and Bowditch Point Park, Gateway Villas is a gated beachfront condominium complex of just 46 residential units, offering rare weekly rental capability—a premier advantage for exceptional income potential on the new Estero Island. Gateway Villas condominium complex has been beautifully revitalized back to "new" and Residene 195, a true 3 bedroom 3 bath, is following suit. Unit 195 occupancy is expected in late Summer 2026 and this brand new seaside Oasis will welcome you. This rare offering is a first floor, over ground. residence ( This is only one of only two spacious 3 bedroom units in the building) At completion, this luxury residence with be finished out with custom shaker cabinetry, quartz counters, Thermador appliances and porcelain tile through out. Gateway offers weekly rentals and Owners and may have pets. Gateway is a gem on the north end of the island. Gateway Villas features a large and welcoming geothermal heated pool, grilling area, and gated ,open parking for owners and guests. Step directly onto the sand with quick and easy beach access right outside your door. Enjoy a short walk to Times Square and the future Estero Island entertainment district—making this an unbeatable location for lifestyle and revenue. With its weekly rental flexibility and unmatched beachfront setting, Gateway Villas remains one of the strongest revenue-producing properties on Estero Island.

500 Estero Blvd Unit 195, Fort Myers Beach
$1,699,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 225077334 MLS ⋅ Seagrape Colony BLDG.
Exceptional coastal investment opportunity on beautiful Fort Myers Beach! This rare property includes a quadplex and a separate beach cottage situated on an oversized 100’ x 110’ double parcel with direct beach access—just steps from the sugar-white sand and turquoise Gulf waters. Located on Mango Street, one of the island’s most desirable Weekly Rental Zoned (STR) streets, this property offers incredible flexibility and income potential. Operate the existing five remodeled rental units for immediate revenue, or redevelop and build two brand-new single-family homes—one on each parcel—creating high-value coastal retreats designed for premium vacation income. There are two separate strap #'s making up this Oversized Assemblage Parcel - 161 Mango St: 19-46-24-W3-0120E.0070 & 163 Mango St: 19-46-24-W3-0120E.0080. Builder introductions available. Rental information available. The existing buildings are totally remodeled, turn-key, and ready for guests. Each residence captures the laid-back coastal charm of Fort Myers Beach, with bright, open interiors and tropical outdoor spaces. There’s also room for a pool to further enhance guest appeal and rental performance. The location is unbeatable—guests can walk to Margaritaville, the Pier District, marinas, Doc Ford’s, local shops, and beachside dining, making it one of the most sought-after spots for vacationers. With direct beach access, a strong rental history, and versatile redevelopment potential, this property checks every box for investors seeking both immediate income and long-term appreciation. Whether you envision keeping the current structures as a high-yield short-term rental portfolio, or creating your dream coastal investment homes, this rare double-lot opportunity on Fort Myers Beach delivers endless potential, prime location, and true island lifestyle.

161 / 163 Mango St, Fort Myers Beach
$1,795,000
2025015172 MLS ⋅ Holiday Heights BLDG.
**PRICE IMPROVEMENT OF NEARLY $150,000!** STUNNING & EXPANSIVE unobstructed BAY & WATERFRONT VIEWS across Estero Bay Aquatic Preserve from this OVERSIZED cleared and buildable BAY FRONT lot! Over 100' of spectacular water frontage on over 1/3 of an acre which wakes up to beautiful sunrises across the bay and is only a short distance to Deeded Beach Access & sunsets on the Gulf! ONE OF THE MOST SOUGHT-AFTER WATERFRONT AND BOATING COMMUNITIES ON THE ISLAND, Holiday Heights, is KNOWN FOR ITS HIGHER ELEVATION AND GULF-ACCESS CANALS and warm & friendly community. Build your custom designed dream home on this oversized bay front lot offering awe inspiring views and the best in coastal living! Located mid-island close to Publix grocery store, trolley stop, full service marina, Fresh Catch Exquisite Waterfront Dining & Junkanoo Below Deck for the more casual waterfront dining experience. Don't miss out on this opportunity to own one of the few vacant bay front lots in this desirable mid island neighborhood location!

5636 Williams Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$1,999,000
225070841 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
60 Feet of Waterfront Views – A Bayfront Jewel on San Carlos Island! Waterfront royalty awaits on this rare, 60-foot stretch of bayfront paradise—perfectly positioned with no-bridge boating to the Gulf in just five minutes. This extraordinary property offers a blank canvas for creating a single-family estate or even a stunning duplex worthy of its setting. An optional adjacent parcel (922) MLS #225070838 is also available if you desire a larger estate. Builder referrals are on hand, giving you even more opportunity to bring your vision to life. Spend your days boating to a dozen nearby restaurants for lunch or dinner, or simply savor serene sunsets over the bay from your own backyard. Located a short stroll from the pristine, sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach—yet away from the bustle of heavy traffic—this San Carlos Island address combines true island living with the convenience of Lee County’s streamlined building process. Rarely do opportunities of this caliber present themselves. Here, you can design and build a residence that captures the very best of bayfront living, offering privacy, beauty, and the quintessential Southwest Florida lifestyle.

926 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$2,099,000
225070838 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.
Bayfront Bliss Meets Coastal Adventure – 60 Feet of Waterfront Views - A Lot Like No Other! Unmatched opportunity awaits with this extraordinary Bayfront/Gulf-access property on San Carlos Island. Offering 60 Feet of Panoramic Waterfront Views and effortless access to the Gulf with no-bridge boating in just five minutes. This rare lot provides a pristine canvas for crafting a spectacular single-family estate or an impressive duplex that celebrates Southwest Florida’s coastal lifestyle. The adjacent parcel (926) MLS #225070841 is also available if you desire a larger footprint or wish to create an expansive dream estate. Builder referrals are on hand, giving you even more opportunity to bring your vision to life. Savor breathtaking sunsets and watch a lively parade of boats from your own backyard, or head out to some of the region’s best fishing grounds. With dozens of waterfront restaurants just a short boat ride away, every outing becomes an adventure. Perfectly positioned within walking distance of the sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach—yet tucked away from the bustle of heavy traffic—this San Carlos Island address combines true island living with the convenience of Lee County’s streamlined permitting and building process. Opportunities of this caliber are exceptionally rare, offering the freedom to design a home that captures the very best of bayfront living and the relaxed, vibrant spirit of Southwest Florida.

922 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$1,700,000
225063591 MLS ⋅ Bayland Heights BLDG.
This OVERSIZED Waterfront LOT offers DIRECT GULF ACCESS on the prestigious Estero Bay Aquatic Preserve. 11,230 SQ FT with 123 FT of Bay Frontage and 165 FT Depth is an idyllic Location to BUILD NEW ELEVATED 2 STORY OR 3 STORY BAY FRONT HOME. A perfect setting to watch the dolphins and manatees play from your very own dock. PARADISE AWAITS!! BIG BOATERS BAYFRONT DREAM! Get lost in your own SUNSHINE DAYDREAM with sweeping BAY views and 165 feet of seawall, this remarkable lot presents the perfect opportunity to build your dream home. Located on a quiet and private areas of Estero Island. Just a short stroll to the Publix grocery store and the Marina. This ONE-OF-A-KIND LOT offers the opportunity to create your own coastal living MASTERPIECE. With boundless potential at your fingertips, you have the freedom to design a residence perfectly tailored to your unique lifestyle and preferences. Let your imagination run wild as you envision luxurious living spaces, expansive outdoor entertainment areas, and every amenity imaginable. Seize this opportunity to turn your dreams into reality and make your mark on this unparalleled waterfront canvas! Don't miss this opportunity to elevate your waterfront lifestyle to new heights! Come be a part of the Fort Myers Beach Renaissance. Onsite multiple builder introductions are available.

4851 Dolphin Ln, Fort Myers Beach
$1,500,000
225054138 MLS ⋅ Fort Myers Beach BLDG.
Waterfront Opportunity on the North End of Fort Myers Beach Discover a rare canal-front lot in one of Fort Myers Beach’s most peaceful and sought-after neighborhoods. Previously home to a 4-unit building, this property offers the flexibility to rebuild as a fourplex or design your dream single-family home. Set among newly built single-family residences, this location combines tranquility with convenience—just a 3-minute stroll to the vibrant energy of Times Square, where you’ll find popular spots like Mr. Waves Island Bar and more. Enjoy direct canal access leading straight into the bay—ideal for boating and waterfront living. An existing pool from the original structure still remains on-site and may offer restoration potential.

151 Matanzas St, Fort Myers Beach
$1,999,999
3 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 225039184 MLS ⋅ Not Applicable BLDG.
GREAT OPPORTUNITY to own property in the Time Square Area of Fort Myers Beach! Lot is zoned commercial for 10 units and below! This Duplex offers a 2 bedroom 1 bathroom upstairs and a 1 bedroom 2 bath downstairs. This lot has 70 FEET of Frontage, dock, fish cleaning station, boat lift, large grass backyard (with irrigation) & 2 patios facing the water. Just steps away from the BEACH, DINING, SHOPPING & ENTERTAINMENT! You cannot get any closer to the hustle & bustle Fort Myers Beach! Whether you're an investor, looking for your own vacation cottage, looking to build something more to suit your needs, or even a bed & breakfast this property has it! Seller Financing is available to qualified Buyers. **Select photos include AI-generated conceptual renderings illustrating potential renovation possibilities. Renderings are for visualization purposes only and do not represent the property's current condition. Improvements shown are not included in the sale, and no representation is made regarding feasibility, permitting, cost, or approval**

340 Crescent St, Fort Myers Beach
$1,500,000
225028955 MLS ⋅ Grand Ole Man BLDG.
Don't miss out on this opportunity! Discover a rare opportunity to own a slice of paradise on the highly desirable South end of Fort Myers Beach! This spacious vacant lot offers the perfect canvas to build your dream beach home or investment property. Nestled in a vibrant coastal community, this property is just steps away from the sugar-white sands and clear blue waters of the Gulf of America! Located in a weekly rental zone, 7 day rental minimum, 52 rentals a year, opportunity is there for investment income! Buy your future lot now to join the future development going on at Fort Myers Beach! New Pass Bridge is completed with a new higher 4 lane bridge, Sanitni Plaza is now open, NEW Fort Myers Beach Pier Installation in 2027, Margaritaville is fully up and running, and many other future developments are in the works along the beach!

7902 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,200,000
225021640 MLS ⋅ Mcphie Park BLDG.
Discover this exceptional BUILD READY double and a half lot positioned directly across from the sugar-white sands of Fort Myers Beach. This rare SWFL offering presents unlimited potential in one of the area's most desirable coastal locations. Envision your dream beach home just steps from paradise - a spacious custom residence with Gulf views, outdoor entertainment areas, and the soothing soundtrack of nearby waves. Design the luxury single-family retreat you've always imagined, perfectly positioned for effortless beach days and breathtaking sunsets. Alternatively, capitalize on this prime location with a savvy investment strategy. The parcel presents exciting opportunities for multi-unit development, creating vacation rentals or long-term residences in this high-demand coastal corridor. With Fort Myers Beach's year-round appeal, rental potential here is truly exceptional. Beyond the beach, enjoy easy access to island dining, boutique shopping, and vibrant entertainment. Explore nearby nature preserves, tee off at championship golf courses, or boat in the warm Gulf waters - all part of the coveted Southwest Florida lifestyle. This versatile property offers more than just land - it's your gateway to beachside living and potential income generation in one of Florida's most treasured coastal communities. A truly extraordinary opportunity awaits the discerning buyer ready to build their vision across from Fort Myers Beach.

5755 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$1,900,000
225021748 MLS ⋅ Acreage BLDG.
***PRICE REDUCTION*** PRIME FORT MYERS BEACH WATERFRONT INDUSTRIAL/COMMERCIAL LAND. Located at the foot of the Matanzas Pass Bridge, the 0.62 acre property boasts 280 feet of frontage along Matanzas Pass and is located in the San Carlos Island water-dependent overlay zone. Additionally, with it's location, it falls under the purview of the federally maintained and regulated channel located along Ostego Bay/Matanzas Pass. There is a submerged land lease of 9,969 sq. ft. Although zoned as industrial, the property has redevelopment opportunities for future use. The property was formerly used by Olsen Marine, a boat service and repair company, which used the property's existing one (1) haul out slip, three (3) transient slips and five (5) private slips. In all, there are 13 slips based on the Manatee Protection Program with a substantion number of slips that can be obtained by Lee County. The property allows for access to Matanzas Pass Bridge with a clearance of 65 feet. The property also has frontage of Main Street of 45 feet. The existing repair shop/warehouse suffered damage from Hurricane Ian but the rest of the lot has been cleared of any storm debris. PURCHASE MONEY FINANCING WILL BE CONSIDERED.

1100 Main St, Fort Myers Beach
Start Your Search