Explore Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000 Map Search

Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Welcome to your dedicated resource for Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000 in Fort Myers Beach, FL. This page is your live portal for listings that match the exact homes for sale you demand, filtering out irrelevant properties to save you time. As a local Fort Myers Beach, FL agent, Broker Brothers specializes in the unique market dynamics of this area, offering insights into amenities, home values, and investment potential. Start exploring the properties currently available between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000 below, or contact a local agent to discuss the details that matters most to your search.

< Back to all Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Search Fort Myers Beach, FL by Price

All Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

$2,999,999
226025842 MLS ⋅ Hercules Park BLDG.
Where Beachfront Bliss Meets Coastal Luxury. This is your chance to own 100 feet of pristine Gulf-front property in the heart of Fort Myers Beach—where the charm of a classic beach town meets the elegance of modern coastal living. Whether you envision a grand seaside estate or a pair of exclusive residences, this premier lot at 4050 Estero Boulevard offers limitless potential. Ideally located, you're just moments from popular waterfront dining at Doc Ford’s, the lively Fort Myers Beach Town Square, and the newly unveiled Margaritaville Hotel. From your own backyard, experience the best of luxury and leisure—soak in breathtaking sunsets, set sail for a day on the water, kayak along tranquil shores, or indulge in the vibrant nightlife. As Fort Myers Beach enters its next great chapter, this rare gulf-front property is your opportunity to be part of the transformation—where relaxed beachside living and upscale coastal elegance seamlessly come together. The future of Fort Myers Beach is here—build your dream home and experience the best of both worlds.

4050 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,575,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 225080635 MLS ⋅ Cases BLDG.
NEW CONSTRUCTION ON FORT MYERS BEACH! Welcome to luxurious and modern coastal island living on Fort Myers Beach. This exceptional new construction residence is thoughtfully designed to embrace the laid-back elegance of FMB, while offering modern coastal finishes, spacious comfort inside, and expansive outdoor living space on all three levels. Featuring 4 large bedrooms, 4 full baths, and 3,300 square feet of beautifully planned living space, this modern coastal retreat showcases an expansive great room concept, creating the perfect setting for entertaining family and friends. With two oversized northwest-facing decks you can soak in breathtaking sunsets, gentle Gulf breezes, and the relaxed rhythm of beach life. Step outside to your own private tropical oasis featuring a stunning resort-style pool and spa complete with a sun shelf, providing the ultimate space to relax, unwind, and entertain in style. Designed with bright and airy modern coastal finishes, every detail has been curated to deliver a sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere. The chef-inspired kitchen, luxurious bathrooms, and premium finishes throughout will reflect the highest standards of quality and craftsmanship. Perfectly positioned in a highly sought-after mid-island location, this property sits on a weekly rental street, presenting an outstanding opportunity for both personal enjoyment and investment potential. Just steps from the sugar-white sands of Fort Myers Beach, you'll also enjoy convenient access to local shopping, waterfront restaurants, marinas, and all the attractions that make island living so desirable. Whether you're searching for a luxurious primary residence, an unforgettable vacation home, or an exceptional income-producing property, this extraordinary new construction home offers the very best of Fort Myers Beach living.

101 Anchorage St, Fort Myers Beach
$2,650,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 2026024527 MLS ⋅ Gulf Heights BLDG.
Experience the ultimate Southwest Florida beach lifestyle in this stunning newer-construction Fort Myers Beach residence, perfectly positioned just steps from the sugar-sand shores of the Gulf with deeded beach access directly across the street. This exceptional 5-bedroom, 5-bathroom home offers luxury, comfort, and investment potential as a highly successful vacation rental with future bookings already in place. Designed with both entertaining and relaxation in mind, four of the five bedrooms serve as spacious primary suites, each featuring walk-in closets and private en-suite bathrooms. An elevator provides access to all three levels, while travertine flooring flows throughout the home. The third-floor great room is the heart of the home, showcasing breathtaking Gulf views and opening to an oversized balcony where you can enjoy sunsets and coastal breezes. The thoughtfully designed floor plan also includes a game room, creating endless opportunities for family fun and guest entertainment. Step outside to your private tropical oasis featuring a resort-style pool and spa, complemented by a unique outdoor poolside projector for unforgettable movie nights. Offered fully turnkey, this property is ready for immediate enjoyment or continued rental success. Whether you're seeking a luxury beach retreat, an income-producing investment property, or both, this extraordinary Fort Myers Beach home delivers an unparalleled coastal living experience.

5335 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,720,000
226021229 MLS ⋅ Damkohlers Subd BLDG.
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. A Rare Opportunity to Craft a Gulf-Front Masterpiece. Perfectly located in the HIGHLY DESIRABLE 3000 Block of Fort Myers Beach. Imagine UNLIMITED SUNSETS every day from your Coastal Retreat. Discover an extraordinary offering along one of the most coveted stretches of shoreline on the island—an Amazing Gulf-front homesite where the possibilities for creating a world-class coastal retreat are as limitless as the horizon itself. This exceptional parcel stands as a rare invitation to design and build a bespoke luxury residence, tailored to the exact standards and lifestyle of its future owner. Poised gracefully on an immaculate span of sugar-white sand, the property is framed by a natural tapestry of low-lying coastal vegetation, enhancing both the beauty and privacy of the setting. This subtle, organic buffer evokes the timeless charm of “Old Florida”, creating an intimate sense of seclusion while still allowing the rhythmic sound of Gulf waves to become the soundtrack of daily life. Here, your outdoor living, pool, and entertainment areas can fully embrace the serene, uninterrupted ambiance that only true Gulf-front living can provide. The location is nothing short of ideal—perfectly balanced between tranquility and convenience. Enjoy quick access to the refined dining, boutique shopping, and vibrant energy of the North End, while returning home to the peaceful stretch of beach renowned for its quiet elegance and understated exclusivity. It is a setting that feels worlds away, yet remains close to everything that makes the island such an extraordinary destination. Whether you envision a private luxury compound, a seasonal coastal haven, or an investment property designed for premium return, this homesite offers the scale, flexibility, and design freedom to realize a truly exceptional estate. With sweeping Gulf vistas, dramatic sunsets, and a setting that elevates every architectural possibility, the canvas is ready for your vision. Opportunities of this caliber are exceptionally rare. Become part of the island’s remarkable renaissance and let your dream of GULF-FRONT living in PARADISE take shape on this premier homesite. Introductions to highly regarded, well-qualified luxury builders are available upon request.

3610 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,699,999
2026023063 MLS ⋅ Mcphie Park BLDG.
A Rare Opportunity to Acquire One of the Largest Direct Gulf-Access Waterfront Estates on Fort Myers Beach Nestled at 175 and 191 Bahia Via, this exceptional combined parcel represents a truly singular offering the largest single-family, direct Gulf-access property currently available on the island. Spanning over an acre with remarkable waterfront presence, the possibilities here are as expansive as the views. Envision subdividing the site to create multiple distinguished residences, crafting a private family compound, or designing your ultimate dream beach home. The existing structure offers potential for thoughtful renovation and modernization, while the grounds provide a pristine canvas for new construction. (Prospective buyers are encouraged to conduct their own due diligence regarding subdivision and development opportunities.) The property boasts impressive amenities, including a refreshing swimming pool, 309 feet of seawall frontage along a protected basin, multiple docks, and two boat lifts, all ensuring effortless Gulf access. Just a short stroll or bike ride away, you’ll find pristine white-sand beaches, vibrant restaurants, entertainment venues, and everyday conveniences. This is more than a property, it is a rare and one-of-a-kind waterfront legacy on Fort Myers Beach.

175 Bahia Via, Fort Myers Beach
$2,875,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 226017363 MLS ⋅ Waterside At Bay Beach BLDG.
IMMEDIATE OCCUPANCY! One of London Bay's remaining furnished residences in the newest and final tower in the gated community of Waterside at Bay Beach Lane. The wait is over for new construction on Fort Myers Beach/Estero Island, Florida's "Gold Coast". Enjoy this limited opportunity to be part of Grandview at Bay Beach, on the southern tip of Estero Island, just a stone's throw from Lover's Key, nestled between Fort Myers & Bonita Springs/Naples, where days begin with glorious sunrises, are spent leisurely shelling, beaching and boating, and end with amazing sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico. Grandview at Bay Beach is the ONLY new construction tower with WALKABILITY to the beach. Grandview is within walking distance to shopping, restaurants, a full-service marina, and in close proximity to RSW airport. This is truly a unique opportunity with limited residences available! Welcome to elevated waterfront living on Estero Island at Grandview. CONTACT US TODAY FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF REMAINING RESIDENCES!

4142 Bay Beach Ln Unit 301, Fort Myers Beach
$3,490,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 226017696 MLS ⋅ Grand Ole Man BLDG.
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Engineered for resilience and designed to stand apart, this distinctive octagon-shaped, elevated beachfront residence on the coveted south end of Fort Myers Beach offers a rare combination of architectural strength and coastal elegance. Its unique structural design enhances durability against coastal elements while maximizing panoramic Gulf views—creating both peace of mind and a truly one-of-a-kind living experience. A truly unique gem, the home features 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, plus a spacious loft with a bunk bed to accommodate additional guests. Currently operating as a successful income-generating property, it presents immediate appeal for investors seeking strong rental performance in one of Southwest Florida’s most desirable beachfront markets. Positioned on an expansive 85-foot-wide beachfront lot, the property offers exceptional scale and direct, unobstructed access to the Gulf, with the sand and shoreline just steps from your door. The elevated construction and proven resilience further enhance long-term value, while sweeping water views and unforgettable sunsets define the lifestyle. Ideally located, the south end provides a quieter, more residential setting while still offering convenient access to Naples, Bonita Springs, and Southwest Florida International Airport. Nearby shopping, dining, and entertainment options add to the appeal for both personal enjoyment and vacation rental guests. Whether you’re expanding your portfolio or securing a distinctive beachfront retreat with immediate income potential, this property delivers on every level—design, durability, location, and lifestyle.

8246 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,999,000
226017467 MLS ⋅ La Villa BLDG.
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Positioned along one of the most visible and rapidly evolving corridors on Fort Myers Beach, 2700 Estero Boulevard presents a rare, high-exposure commercial opportunity on the coveted beachside of Estero Blvd—just a short ~300-foot stroll to the Gulf’s white sand shoreline. Formerly home to a 14-unit boutique hotel, this cleared parcel is primed for redevelopment, offering exceptional flexibility for a wide range of luxury or mixed-use concepts. Whether envisioning an upscale boutique hotel, branded residences, or a thoughtfully curated mixed-use destination, the site delivers the scale, positioning, and surrounding momentum that sophisticated investors seek. Directly across the street, the beautifully maintained Fort Myers Beach Library creates a serene and established backdrop, while the newly approved Myerside Resort development—featuring a dynamic mix of residential, hospitality, and curated dining—signals strong forward growth and long-term value. Seagrape Plaza is also just steps away, providing immediate access to additional retail and dining options. The location is further enhanced by its proximity to the vibrant downtown district—just minutes away—and approximately one mile from the iconic Margaritaville Resort, placing this property within the heart of the island’s revitalization. For added convenience and accessibility, the Fort Myers Beach Shuttle’s final stop is located directly in front of the site, offering seamless connectivity for future guests or residents. Beach Access #24, located at the end of Pompano Street, provides direct entry to the shoreline just moments away—an invaluable asset for any hospitality or residential development. With unmatched frontage, premier visibility, and strong surrounding development activity, 2700 Estero Boulevard represents a compelling opportunity to create a landmark coastal project in one of Southwest Florida’s most sought-after beachfront markets.

2700 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,990,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026017632 MLS ⋅ Indian Bayou Subd BLDG.
Rare Bayfront Duplex Opportunity on Fort Myers Beach Stunning bayfront duplex offering the best of both worlds—direct boating access and a short walk to the beach. Located at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, this property features approximately 6,101 sq ft under air (unit B 3,006 sq ft unit A 3,095 sq ft) and is built on concrete pilings, effectively creating a 3-level structure. Professionally remodeled following hurricane damage, including installation of new code-compliant hurricane shutters. Multiple balconies and large windows provide expansive bay views from upper levels. Each unit offers: Top floor primary suite with balcony, dual walk-in closets, and spacious bathroom Second level with 2 bedrooms and Jack & Jill bathroom Main living area with open kitchen, dining, and 2-story great room with balcony Ground level garage space with capacity for multiple vehicles The property offers flexible use options: live in one side and rent the other, short- or long-term rental investment, or combine both units through existing interior access points on each level. Previously operated as a vacation rental property and will be reintroduced into a rental program. Property is offered turnkey furnished, excluding personal items and select artwork. Recent updates include: New metal roof Updated A/C systems Vinyl flooring Impact sliding doors (primary suites) Pool resurfacing with new tile and spa New pool equipment Additional features: Elevator shaft (currently non-operational) Mangrove trimming permit in place (recently completed) 3 separate parcel IDs (per county records) Important notes: Dock was damaged by Hurricane Ian and will require replacement (information available) Property is sold as-is Showings by appointment only.

21500 - 21504 Indian Bayou Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$2,825,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026014769 MLS ⋅ Bayfront BLDG.
Luxury NEW CONSTRUCTION home offering elevated coastal living in this spectacular Florida Beach Vernacular masterpiece, showcasing 80 feet of pristine water frontage. Designed for refined beach-island living, this residence seamlessly blends modern sophistication with relaxed coastal elegance. The thoughtfully designed interior features three spacious bedrooms and two beautifully appointed bathrooms, complemented by an open-concept living area that maximizes natural light and captures serene water views throughout, generator ready with transfer switch installed. At the heart of the home, the gourmet chef’s kitchen impresses with top-of-the-line appliances, custom cabinetry, and an elegant built-in wine bar, creating the perfect setting for entertaining and everyday luxury. Seamless indoor-outdoor living enhances the coastal lifestyle, with ample space to relax, entertain, and enjoy waterfront surroundings. Ideally located near Fort Myers Beach, this exceptional property offers convenient access to white-sand beaches, boating, dining, and entertainment. Step outside to an expansive balcony, a natural extension of the living space, offering breathtaking Intracoastal views and unforgettable sunsets.--perfect for enjoying time with family or friends. Outdoor living continues with a covered patio, perfect for lounging, dining, and hosting gatherings, and a resort-style backyard featuring a sparkling pool, tiki hut, and expansive deck overlooking the water. A true boater’s paradise, the property includes a private lift with direct bay access, no fixed bridges, and unobstructed routes to the Gulf. Built to the latest construction standards, it features hurricane-impact windows and doors and is elevated above current flood requirements, providing safety and peace of mind. Additional highlights include an oversized one-car garage with ample storage and a climate-controlled bonus room ideal for flexible use or extra storage., **Do not miss it**

445 Madison Ct, Fort Myers Beach
$2,500,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026012584 MLS ⋅ Holiday Heights BLDG.
Newly built elevated gulf access pool home located in the desirable Holiday Heights neighborhood on Fort Myers Beach. Completed in 2025 and gently used since, this 3 bedroom 2 bathroom home offers a coastal feel with quality design and beautiful finishes. You may ascend to the living area using 1 of 2 composite staircases or call for your private elevator to transport you up to the property. Once inside you will admire the great room, teeming with natural light through the impact windows, complete with formal dining for 10, a comfy yet sophisticated living room, and sensational kitchen outfitted with stainless steel appliances, marble island, wine fridge, and 4-person breakfast bar. The spacious primary bedroom, with pocket sliders leading out to the deck and ensuite bathroom, provides a quiet sanctuary for the owners. You will find 2 guest bedrooms separated by a beautifully appointed bathroom on the other side of the home, perfect for families or guests. Once back downstairs and outside you can enjoy a large heated saltwater pool with sun shelf overlooking the canal with views of the bay. When you are ready to hit the water, the newly constructed dock with electric boat lift is the perfect spot to store your vessel. This beach property is located just minutes from Publix , shopping and dining options of Santini Plaza, and the Margaritaville Resort.

5545 Avenida Pescadora, Fort Myers Beach
$2,600,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 2026013211 MLS ⋅ Fort Myers Beach BLDG.
Be one of the first to buy a newly constructed beach cottage in Paradise Point on Fort Myers Beach. Located on the north end of the beach, close to the Pink Shell Resort and just minutes to Time Square and Margaritaville. Easy access on and off the island from this address. The previous Paradise Point Cottages were known for the fun and colorful cottages build in the 60's and 70's and now are being replaced with current code, elevated, hurricane resistant construction, unique and colorful custom beach cottages. The cottage is second in from Estero Blvd and third in from the beach in a row of four lots. This cottage is in the weekly rental area of the island. The cottage is currently under construction with an anticipated completion by the end of this year, 2026.

452 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
Start Your Search