Homes for Sale Over $3,500,000 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

2026028720 MLS

Commercial Retail / Apt. Bld. On one of the HIGHEST TRAFFIC COUNT LOCATIONS ON FORT MYERS BEACH! Amazing High Visibility Commercial Property Location ! Once-in-a-cycle opportunity to own a turnkey 3 apartment rental with a professional local Rental Management company in place that handles all the apartment rentals and is producing income for the owner. Plus a 2,700 Sq. Ft. ground floor commercial space ready for owner user or new tenant in the heart of Fort Myers Beach, just feet from the sand. Also has small seawall canal access to the Bay and Gulf. Recent remodel inside and out 2018/2023 Commercial Building, Corner of Estero Blvd. and Crescent St. This 2 Floor Building is located next door to one of the newest Margaritaville Resorts / Hotel on Fort Myers Beach, Florida and just a few steps across the street from the Margaritaville Beach Front Pool / Water Park that is open to the public for a fee and steps from the Public Beach Access in the Heart of the Busiest part of the Island. High Traffic and High Pedestrian walking area. In season thousands of cars and people driving and walking by this location daily. Existing and operating is (3) residential Rental Boutique Apartments upstairs delivering immediate income. Downstairs at the ground pedestrian level floor is aprox. 2,700 Sq. Ft. of Commercial Space. This ground floor commercial space is ready to use for a owner user or lease out to a tenant. It is possible under Town rules to use the front (old parking area) for extra space. You could have additional usable space. For example, food use tables and chairs out there and also install a awning from the building all the way out to the start of the sidewalk to provide a open air shade and rain free space Great for Retail, Restaurant, Bar, Ice Cream, Pizza, Sandwich / National Chain shop, Office space or many other commercial uses. Fantastic ! Location for a Iconic Brand. Walkable access to vibrant resort amenities, and local Beach attractions , dining destinations and the white sugar sand Beach the island is World Renowned for. Surrounded by premier Hotels, nightlife and entertainment in the high demand commercial Fort Myers Beach Downtown corridor. Total Remodeled in 2018 A/C, Roof, Plumbing, Electric, Misc. and Building remodeled and repair 2/1/2024 permit date, building and apartments are like new. Total Building Sq. Ft. : 5,568, Total Lot Size : 7,309 Sq. Ft. / 0.16 acres, Year built : 1967 Town of Fort Myers Beach Zoned : "Downtown" and the property has a Zero Parking requirement approved by the Town. Dont miss owning this Trophy Asset.

1161 Estero Blvd Unit 1165, Fort Myers Beach

$6,500,000

2026028037 MLS

Location***Location***Location This waterfront location offers endless possibilities. The property is located in the downtown zoning area directly across from Margaritaville Resort, offering approximately 100' of water frontage with docks and direct access. This is an incredible opportunity to be part of the rebuild on Fort Myers Beach. 4COP liquor license available with acceptable offer.

1167 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$8,975,000

226023612 MLS ⋅ Gulf Heights BLDG.

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. 5300 Estero Boulevard presents an exceptional Gulf-front investment and development opportunity on Fort Myers Beach. This rare assemblage consists of four contiguous parcels totaling over ½ acre, offering approximately 90 feet of direct Gulf frontage and 270 feet of depth. The assemblage includes two Gulf-front parcels and two Estero Boulevard parcels, all zoned for single-family residential development, creating an outstanding opportunity for luxury beachfront homes or a multi-home investment project. For an even larger development opportunity, 5300 Estero Boulevard can be combined with the adjoining 5256 Estero Boulevard assemblage, creating approximately 1 acre with 180 feet of continuous Gulf frontage, one of the largest contiguous beachfront holdings on Fort Myers Beach. The combined assemblage offers the potential for up to eight luxury single-family homes, or the opportunity to create a signature Gulf-front resort-style development, subject to all applicable approvals and permitting. With extremely limited Gulf-front inventory and continued redevelopment on Fort Myers Beach, this unique offering represents an extraordinary opportunity for investors, developers, and portfolio builders seeking exceptional scale, long-term appreciation, and lasting value in one of Southwest Florida's most desirable beachfront locations.

5300 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$8,975,000

6 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 226023614 MLS ⋅ Gulf Heights BLDG.

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. 5256 Estero Boulevard presents a rare and captivating Gulf-to-Boulevard assemblage on Fort Myers Beach. Spanning over ½ acre with 90 feet of direct Gulf frontage and approximately 270 feet of depth, this exceptional offering provides an unmatched opportunity for investors, developers, or those seeking to create a legacy beachfront estate. (See the adjoining 5300 Estero assemblage for additional Gulf-front opportunities.) The property consists of three parcels, including two Gulf-front single-family residences offering a combined 8 bedrooms, 6.5 bathrooms, and more than 4,500 square feet of living space, along with a large multifamily parcel extending to Estero Boulevard. This rear parcel can also be divided into two single-family homesites, creating an irreplaceable development footprint in one of Southwest Florida's most desirable beachfront locations. Zoned for weekly rentals and new elevated construction with private pools, the property offers exceptional flexibility for luxury vacation homes, a boutique beachfront resort, an exclusive residential compound, or a high-performing income-producing investment. The weekly rental zoning significantly enhances the property's revenue potential while maximizing future development opportunities. For those seeking an even larger vision, 5256 Estero Boulevard can be combined with the adjacent 5300 Estero assemblage, creating nearly one acre with approximately 180 feet of continuous Gulf frontage—one of the largest and most prestigious contiguous beachfront holdings on Fort Myers Beach. With extremely limited Gulf-front inventory and the island's continued redevelopment, this is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to secure a premier beachfront investment offering exceptional scale, outstanding income potential, long-term value, and lasting legacy appeal in the heart of Fort Myers Beach.

5256 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$4,999,999

2026026808 MLS

Rare real estate opportunity with great potential for development! The property has an architecturally unique building and ample land space offering a wide range of possibilities for development. Currently zoned for commercial/retail/restaurant. The property's location with 635 feet of frontage on San Carlos Blvd., on the way to Fort Myers Beach, is a prime spot for tourism-related developments. The proximity to a popular tourist destination, including Margaritaville, can be a significant advantage for attracting visitors. The existing 14,000 square-foot building with open air center space, restaurants, and kitchens could be repurposed to fit the desired development plan. This can save time and resources compared to building from scratch. OWNER FINANCING available. Development Potential: The zoning allows for 21 units with the potential for more through further study and permitting offers flexibility in the type and scale of development that can be undertaken on the property. The option to develop an all-inclusive resort, hotels, condos, shopping plaza, or rental units provides a variety of possibilities to explore. The availability of an additional 2.3 acres of adjoining property presents an opportunity to expand the development project further at an additional expense. This can allow for a more comprehensive and cohesive density development plan.

17650 San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$6,900,000

226022843 MLS

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Strategically located on Main Street, this waterfront property offers all the beauty and water access of Fort Myers Beach. The zoning and development oversight is through unincorporated Lee County. The potential includes positive density and greater height for buildings to maximize water views and to better ensure project profitability. The Fort Myers Beach area is on the road to significant revitalization. This property maximizes all the benefits of a waterfront location without the traffic or redevelopment uncertainty. The docks have all been recently rebuilt. There are several waterfront restaurants within view that are only a couple minutes on foot or by boat. The property is currently zoned Light Industrial (IL) but also allows for some living units on this property as well. The future land use is Industrial. However, based on current uses, and the need for development on and near Fort Myers Beach, it is believed that Lee County is open to additional uses. We recommend that all plans should be verified independently with Lee County. ALL PROPERTIES ARE BEING SOLD “AS IS” Portfolio includes 1120,1122, 1130 and 1138 Main Street.

1138 Main St, Fort Myers Beach

$6,900,000

226022841 MLS

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Strategically located on Main Street, this waterfront property offers all the beauty and water access of Fort Myers Beach. The zoning and development oversight is through unincorporated Lee County. The potential includes positive density and greater height for buildings to maximize water views and to better ensure project profitability. The Fort Myers Beach area is on the road to significant revitalization. This property maximizes all the benefits of a waterfront location without the traffic or redevelopment uncertainty. The docks have all been recently rebuilt. There are several waterfront restaurants within view that are only a couple minutes on foot or by boat. The property is currently zoned Light Industrial (IL) but also allows for some living units on this property as well. The future land use is Industrial. However, based on current uses, and the need for development on and near Fort Myers Beach, it is believed that Lee County is open to additional uses. We recommend that all plans should be verified independently with Lee County. ALL PROPERTIES ARE BEING SOLD “AS IS” Portfolio includes 1120,1122, 1130 and 1138 Main Street.

1120 Main St, Fort Myers Beach

$6,900,000

226022844 MLS

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Strategically located on Main Street, this waterfront property offers all the beauty and water access of Fort Myers Beach. The zoning and development oversight is through unincorporated Lee County. The potential includes positive density and greater height for buildings to maximize water views and to better ensure project profitability. The Fort Myers Beach area is on the road to significant revitalization. This property maximizes all the benefits of a waterfront location without the traffic or redevelopment uncertainty. The docks have all been recently rebuilt. There are several waterfront restaurants within view that are only a couple minutes on foot or by boat. The property is currently zoned Light Industrial (IL) but also allows for some living units on this property as well. The future land use is Industrial. However, based on current uses, and the need for development on and near Fort Myers Beach, it is believed that Lee County is open to additional uses. We recommend that all plans should be verified independently with Lee County. ALL PROPERTIES ARE BEING SOLD “AS IS” Portfolio includes 1120,1122, 1130 and 1138 Main Street.

1122 Main St, Fort Myers Beach

$4,050,000

226017354 MLS ⋅ Old Pelican Bay BLDG.

This newly developed Homesite 23, 1 of 24, in the exciting boating community of Old Pelican Bay Estate in Siesta Isle. Just minutes from the Gulf with no bridges in the way. The deep passage canal will accommodate larger boats with deep water to the San Carlos Channel to the Gulf. The buyer will be required to sign and build a Minimum 3000 AC square foot two story over garage home with the developer, Claussen Residential Communities . The lot is on the canal. The lot comes with dock rights. The street is a pervious brick paver. The developer has four plans for review and will do custom home

18420 Old Pelican Bay Dr, Fort Myers Beach

$6,000,000

2026019063 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.

Rare opportunity to own a prime beachfront development site on beautiful Fort Myers Beach! This unique offering includes two adjoining lots being sold together, boasting approximately 105+/- feet of direct Gulf frontage and endless possibilities for investors, developers, or those seeking an exceptional coastal property. The combined parcels are approved to accommodate up to five cottages, with five water hookups already in place, adding tremendous value and convenience for future development. Ideally situated next door to the Best Western Plus Beach Resort, with residential property on the opposite side, this location provides the perfect blend of accessibility, neighboring amenities, and privacy. Enjoy all that Fort Myers Beach has to offer, including waterfront dining, boutique shopping, boating, swimming, sunbathing, and vibrant entertainment. Just moments away is the popular Margaritaville resort destination, making this property even more desirable. Whether you're looking to build income producing vacation cottages, a private beachfront retreat, or capitalize on one of Southwest Florida’s most sought after beach communities, this is an exceptional opportunity to invest in paradise. Strap #'s for both lots are 24-46-23-W4-00400.013A (approx .55 acres) & 24-46-23-W4-00400.013D (approx .33acres)

650 & 632 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$4,250,000

2026018662 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.

Estero Bay is every boaters dream location with endless water views on the exclusive North End of Fort Myers Beach. Here’s your opportunity to own one of the few remaining large parcels that can support a truly grand, private estate in this beautiful boater's community. Tucked away on a quiet cul de sac, this rare property offers the perfect blend of seclusion and proximity, with the connecting lot also available for sale (MLS#2025007080) —it's an ideal location for the ultimate waterfront compound. The adjoining 16,000 square foot parcel allows you to expand your footprint to nearly an acre of waterfront bliss, all with direct Gulf access, panoramic water views, and room to accommodate large yachts. This site offers everything the most discerning buyers seek—privacy, spectacular water views, and an unrivaled location just minutes from Times Square, Margaritaville, and the island’s top hotspots. The shoreline features 200 feet of protected seawall and intersecting canal frontage with the bonus exceptional deepwater access. Combining both lots would transform the property into an expansive waterfront retreat—perfect for hosting, relaxing, or simply enjoying the horizon from sunrise to sunset.The property is development ready with $350,000 design plans included by acclaimed architect Rich Guzman and styled by Adelyn Interiors. The plans showcase a sleek 6,075 sq. ft. estate with around 17,000 sq. ft. of outdoor living, including an elevated infinity pool, wrap around decks, and multiple outdoor lounges—blurring the line between indoors and out. Utilities are in place for a smooth start and every interior detail has been carefully curated for a flawless finish with the option to customize to your taste. This large site offers endless possibilities—add guest quarters, luxury amenities, or create a sprawling compound. With the ability to combine both parcels, you’re looking at a rare opportunity to build one of the most impressive estates on the island, fully tailored to your vision. Whether you choose to build on one of the lots or both, your vision starts here.

645 Matanzas Ct, Fort Myers Beach

$11,900,000

6 Beds ⋅ 8.5 Baths ⋅ 226014375 MLS ⋅ Laguna Shores BLDG.

EXCEPTIONAL NEW CONSTRUCTION COMPLETED MARCH 2026 — COASTAL LUXURY, PERFECTED! Introducing a newly constructed bayfront residence where uncompromising craftsmanship, architectural elegance, and engineered strength converge in one of Fort Myers Beach’s most desirable locations. A HOME LIKE NO OTHER, this refined coastal home with 12,200 square feet under roof, is designed for durability, beauty, and elevated living, capturing expansive water views across Estero Bay and toward the iconic new FMB bridge—offering dramatic scenery by day and illuminated vistas by night. From inception, solid masonry construction supported by over 130 concrete pilings establishes a foundation of coastal resilience. Concrete floor systems and an Eagle Capistrano cement tile roof enhance long-term performance and peace of mind. The home’s orientation maximizes sweeping bay views while filling the interior with natural light. Handcrafted finishes create a sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere. Statement ceilings showcase curated woods including rift-sawn white oak, sycamore, rift-sawn maple, and curly maple, complemented by custom-milled doors, oversized trim, and crown molding. Large-format shell stone flooring flows throughout main living areas and stairways, while 10-inch-wide engineered white oak flooring adds warmth to bedrooms and the flex lounge. The great room features a custom entertainment wall with a three-sided fireplace and an 85-inch Frame TV. The designer kitchen is appointed with Sub-Zero, Wolf, and Bosch appliances, custom cabinetry, concealed pantry storage, a substantial center island, and Taj Mahal quartzite and Matarazzo dolomite surfaces. Spa-inspired baths include floating cabinetry with integrated electrical outlets, frameless glass showers, and curated tile selections. A private elevator provides seamless access across all levels, while a fully integrated smart home system enhances connectivity and security. Outdoor living offers a resort-style experience overlooking the bay. The expansive outdoor kitchen and entertaining area features custom concrete, shell stone, and stainless cabinetry, a 12-foot powder-coated radius seating bar with Spanish stone top, built-in Infratech radiant heaters, and a 360 Breeze misting fan system. The sculptural pool and spa include a negative-edge spillover, glass tile finishes, sun shelf with bubblers, underwater seating, LED lighting, and a raised spa with dual spillways. A private dock with dual boat lifts and new seawall provide direct bay access. A heated outdoor cabana, fire pit, and pizza oven complete this exceptional waterfront setting. Marine-grade stainless steel and powder-coated railings, power roll-down hurricane and insect screens, and professionally finished exterior elements complete the design. Every detail is thoughtfully selected to deliver luxury without compromise—merging architectural integrity, coastal strength, and an extraordinary bayfront setting.

280 Estrellita Dr, Fort Myers Beach

Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL Over $3,500,000

All Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Over $3,500,000

Broker Brothers LLC

Search

Resources

About