Homes for Sale Over $3,500,000 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Strategically located on Main Street, this waterfront property offers all the beauty and water access of Fort Myers Beach. The zoning and development oversight is through unincorporated Lee County. The potential includes positive density and greater height for buildings to maximize water views and to better ensure project profitability. The Fort Myers Beach area is on the road to significant revitalization. This property maximizes all the benefits of a waterfront location without the traffic or redevelopment uncertainty. The docks have all been recently rebuilt. There are several waterfront restaurants within view that are only a couple minutes on foot or by boat. The property is currently zoned Light Industrial (IL) but also allows for some living units on this property as well. The future land use is Industrial. However, based on current uses, and the need for development on and near Fort Myers Beach, it is believed that Lee County is open to additional uses. We recommend that all plans should be verified independently with Lee County. ALL PROPERTIES ARE BEING SOLD “AS IS” Portfolio includes 1120,1122, 1130 and 1138 Main Street.

1138 Main St, Fort Myers Beach

$6,900,000

226022841 MLS

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Strategically located on Main Street, this waterfront property offers all the beauty and water access of Fort Myers Beach. The zoning and development oversight is through unincorporated Lee County. The potential includes positive density and greater height for buildings to maximize water views and to better ensure project profitability. The Fort Myers Beach area is on the road to significant revitalization. This property maximizes all the benefits of a waterfront location without the traffic or redevelopment uncertainty. The docks have all been recently rebuilt. There are several waterfront restaurants within view that are only a couple minutes on foot or by boat. The property is currently zoned Light Industrial (IL) but also allows for some living units on this property as well. The future land use is Industrial. However, based on current uses, and the need for development on and near Fort Myers Beach, it is believed that Lee County is open to additional uses. We recommend that all plans should be verified independently with Lee County. ALL PROPERTIES ARE BEING SOLD “AS IS” Portfolio includes 1120,1122, 1130 and 1138 Main Street.

1120 Main St, Fort Myers Beach

$6,900,000

226022844 MLS

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Strategically located on Main Street, this waterfront property offers all the beauty and water access of Fort Myers Beach. The zoning and development oversight is through unincorporated Lee County. The potential includes positive density and greater height for buildings to maximize water views and to better ensure project profitability. The Fort Myers Beach area is on the road to significant revitalization. This property maximizes all the benefits of a waterfront location without the traffic or redevelopment uncertainty. The docks have all been recently rebuilt. There are several waterfront restaurants within view that are only a couple minutes on foot or by boat. The property is currently zoned Light Industrial (IL) but also allows for some living units on this property as well. The future land use is Industrial. However, based on current uses, and the need for development on and near Fort Myers Beach, it is believed that Lee County is open to additional uses. We recommend that all plans should be verified independently with Lee County. ALL PROPERTIES ARE BEING SOLD “AS IS” Portfolio includes 1120,1122, 1130 and 1138 Main Street.

1122 Main St, Fort Myers Beach

18420 Old Pelican Bay Dr, Fort Myers Beach

$4,050,000

226017354 MLS ⋅ Old Pelican Bay BLDG.

This newly developed Homesite 23, 1 of 24, in the exciting boating community of Old Pelican Bay Estate in Siesta Isle. Just minutes from the Gulf with no bridges in the way. The deep passage canal will accommodate larger boats with deep water to the San Carlos Channel to the Gulf. The buyer will be required to sign and build a Minimum 3000 AC square foot two story over garage home with the developer, Claussen Residential Communities . The lot is on the canal. The lot comes with dock rights. The street is a pervious brick paver. The developer has four plans for review and will do custom home

18420 Old Pelican Bay Dr, Fort Myers Beach

$6,000,000

2026019063 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.

Rare opportunity to own a prime beachfront development site on beautiful Fort Myers Beach! This unique offering includes two adjoining lots being sold together, boasting approximately 105+/- feet of direct Gulf frontage and endless possibilities for investors, developers, or those seeking an exceptional coastal property. The combined parcels are approved to accommodate up to five cottages, with five water hookups already in place, adding tremendous value and convenience for future development. Ideally situated next door to the Best Western Plus Beach Resort, with residential property on the opposite side, this location provides the perfect blend of accessibility, neighboring amenities, and privacy. Enjoy all that Fort Myers Beach has to offer, including waterfront dining, boutique shopping, boating, swimming, sunbathing, and vibrant entertainment. Just moments away is the popular Margaritaville resort destination, making this property even more desirable. Whether you're looking to build income producing vacation cottages, a private beachfront retreat, or capitalize on one of Southwest Florida’s most sought after beach communities, this is an exceptional opportunity to invest in paradise. Strap #'s for both lots are 24-46-23-W4-00400.013A (approx .55 acres) & 24-46-23-W4-00400.013D (approx .33acres)

650 & 632 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$13,490,000

5 Beds ⋅ 7.5 Baths ⋅ 226008794 MLS ⋅ Flamingo Park BLDG.

A new benchmark in luxury is nearing completion on Fort Myers Beach. Set on a truly extraordinary 80x400-foot beachfront homesite, this one-of-a-kind Alair custom residence is poised to redefine coastal living on the island. Expected to be completed soon and offered fully furnished, this spectacular estate has been curated by a top-tier designer, delivering a rare opportunity to step into a fully realized vision of refined beachfront luxury. Perfectly positioned on the coveted south end of Fort Myers Beach, this remarkable Gulf-front residence enjoys one of the island’s most unique settings—true beachfront living without being directly on Estero Boulevard—offering both privacy and prestige in an exceptional location. Finished in authentic tabby, a timeless blend of shells and concrete that honors the area’s coastal heritage, the home makes an immediate architectural statement while embracing the elegance of modern design. Inside, soaring 12-foot ceilings, walls of impact-rated glass, and expansive 10-foot sliding doors create a dramatic yet welcoming atmosphere, perfectly framing sweeping Gulf views and effortless indoor-outdoor living. Riva Elite European white oak flooring, custom millwork, floating beams, shiplap accents, and thoughtfully designed ceilings bring warmth, texture, and sophistication throughout. The chef’s kitchen is a true showpiece, featuring a premium Sub-Zero, Wolf, and Cove appliance suite, bespoke cabinetry, and striking natural stone surfaces designed for both everyday comfort and elevated entertaining. An oversized laundry room and separate caterer’s kitchen add another layer of functionality for seamless hosting. The home offers five bedrooms, five full baths, and three half baths, including four beautifully appointed guest suites. The primary suite is designed as a private sanctuary, complete with custom architectural detailing, two oversized boutique-style walk-in closets with built-in cabinetry, dual water closets, and a spa-inspired bath with suspended designer mirrors and exceptional natural light. An extraordinary collection of luxury features sets this residence apart, including a temperature-controlled glass wine display for over 600 bottles, two laundry rooms, a main-level entertaining bar, an upper-level morning bar, Lutron lighting controls, Savant home automation, a private elevator, LED-lit shower niches, and illuminated toe-kicks throughout. Outdoor living is just as impressive, offering a resort-style experience with an elevated pool featuring integrated fire elements, expansive lounging areas, a full outdoor kitchen, and a stunning outdoor fireplace finished in leathered Black Diamond quartzite—all positioned to capture unforgettable sunsets over the Gulf. Rare in scale, exceptional in design, and nearly ready for its debut, this fully furnished beachfront masterpiece is more than a home—it is a statement property setting a new tone for luxury real estate on Fort Myers Beach.

6100 Court St, Fort Myers Beach

$6,950,000

6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 226009517 MLS ⋅ Laguna Shores BLDG.

Luxury is rising on the coveted south end of Fort Myers Beach, where this 7-bedroom, 7-bath all-concrete waterfront showpiece—expected to be completed this fall—is set to become one of the most ambitious new homes on the island. Designed for both resilience and refined coastal living, the home features expansive walls of glass, oversized sliding doors, and multiple terraces that capture natural light and water views from nearly every level. Located directly on a deep-water canal with quick Gulf access, the property is ideal for boating enthusiasts and will feature a private boat lift and double jet ski lift for effortless days on the water. The interiors showcase a modern architectural aesthetic with 48” x 48” porcelain flooring throughout the main living areas, dramatic 60” x 120” Italian porcelain in the primary bath, porcelain and marble finishes in secondary baths, quartzite countertops, and Level 5 smooth wall finishes. The chef’s kitchen will be equipped with a fully integrated Miele appliance package, including panel-ready refrigerator and freezer columns, 48” gas cooktop, oven, steam oven, microwave, and built-in coffee system. Additional highlights include two coffee stations, four high-efficiency Carrier HVAC systems, three tankless water heaters, integrated sound, CCTV security, and an oversized elevator servicing the main living levels. Outdoor living centers around a spectacular 12’ x 40’ infinity-edge saltwater pool and spa with Pentair heating and automation, creating a private resort-style setting. The rooftop plaza deck offers breathtaking 360-degree views of the Gulf, Estero Bay, and the island skyline, providing a rare elevated outdoor living space perfect for sunset entertaining. Buyers who secure the property during construction may have the opportunity to participate in the final finishing selections, allowing for personalization of this exceptional residence. Positioned directly on Estero Boulevard, the property also offers excellent vacation rental potential, with its seven-bedroom layout, luxury amenities, and prime south-end location making it a strong candidate for high-income producing rentals.

8223 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$3,500,000

2026012341 MLS ⋅ Fort Myers Beach BLDG.

Commercial - Multi use property, zoned Downtown within the City limits of Ft. Myers Beach. This vacant corner is located just 5 blocks east of Margaritaville and Times Square.

1801 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$3,900,000

2026010404 MLS ⋅ Cases BLDG.

RARELY AVAILABLE — GULF-FRONT OPPORTUNITY ON FORT MYERS BEACH Imagine owning your very own piece of paradise where sugar-white sand, turquoise Gulf waters, and spectacular sunsets become part of your everyday life. This exceptional Gulf-front parcel offers a truly rare opportunity to create a custom coastal residence on one of Southwest Florida’s most sought-after shorelines. Ideally positioned mid-island on Fort Myers Beach, this FULL LOT homesite places you directly along the Gulf, where endless views and the soothing rhythm of the waves provide the ultimate backdrop for relaxed coastal living. Picture morning coffee with the Gulf breeze, afternoons spent barefoot on the beach, and unforgettable evenings watching the sun melt into the horizon—all just steps from your future front door. Beyond the incredible beachfront setting, the location offers the perfect balance of tranquility and convenience. Enjoy an easy walk to the iconic Margaritaville Resort, Times Square, restaurants, shops, entertainment, and the vibrant island lifestyle that makes Fort Myers Beach such a beloved destination. With Gulf-front building opportunities becoming increasingly scarce, this property offers something truly special: a blank canvas to create the coastal retreat you’ve always envisioned. Whether your dream is a luxurious primary residence, a private vacation escape, or an exceptional investment opportunity, this is your chance to build something uniquely yours on the Gulf. The land is here. The Gulf is waiting. Your dream home can be next. Don’t miss this extraordinary opportunity to secure your own slice of Fort Myers Beach and create a legacy property where the best of coastal living is right outside your door.

3250 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$4,499,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6.5 Baths ⋅ 226004709 MLS ⋅ Seagrape BLDG.

Exceptional new construction offering panoramic canal views and positioned on a weekly rental street with strong income potential. This elevated three-level residence features 5 bedrooms and 7 bathrooms and is thoughtfully designed to accommodate up to 20 guests, making it one of the few homes of its kind on the island. The home offers a short walk to the beach, canal access, and an oversized lot, blending luxury coastal living with flexibility for use as a primary residence, second home, or short-term rental. Outdoor living is maximized with a private pool and spa, an expansive rear deck capturing canal breezes, a garage-level tiki bar, and a rooftop deck with sweeping sunrise-to-sunset views. Inside, the open-concept layout features custom furnishings, designer coastal finishes, and a spacious great room ideal for entertaining. The gourmet kitchen includes ample bar seating and flows seamlessly into a large dining area. The main living level offers a built-in bunk room with en-suite bath, while the upper level features four king bedrooms, each with its own private bathroom, providing comfort and privacy for guests. For buyers under contract early, there is potential flexibility to create a main-floor primary suite. Offered fully furnished and rental ready, including furnishings, games, golf cart, ice machine, and more. With strong rental performance in comparable markets, and potential 1031 exchange. This property represents a rare opportunity to own a high-performing island home with exceptional lifestyle appeal.

168 Chapel St, Fort Myers Beach

$3,500,000

2026002687 MLS ⋅ Crescent Beach BLDG.

Prime Mixed-Use Opportunity in Downtown District – Endless Development Potential Build Your Dream on the Gulf – Rare Fort Myers Beach Waterfront Opportunity – Welcome to one of the most coveted offerings on Fort Myers Beach—a stunning direct Gulf-front lot where endless sunsets, sugar-white sand, and panoramic water views set the stage for your ultimate coastal retreat. This is a rare chance to design and build a custom luxury residence in one of Southwest Florida’s most desirable beachfront locations. Wake up to the sound of waves, step directly onto the beach from your own backyard, and enjoy unobstructed views of the Gulf of Mexico from sunrise to sunset. Whether you envision a modern beachfront masterpiece or a classic coastal estate, this prime homesite offers the perfect canvas for a truly exceptional property. Located just minutes from world-class dining, shopping, marinas, and the vibrant Times Square district, this lot combines privacy, prestige, and prime location—making it ideal for both a personal dream home or a high-end investment. Opportunities like this are exceedingly rare. Now is the time to turn this Gulf-front dream into reality.

42 Avenue E, Fort Myers Beach

$4,495,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4.5 Baths ⋅ 2026003671 MLS ⋅ Mcphie Park BLDG.

Overlooking the pristine sands of Fort Myers Beach, this BRAND NEW custom-built 3 story home by Imperial Homes offers the perfect blend of contemporary architecture and classic coastal charm. Designed as the ultimate luxury retreat, this 4,392 sq. ft. residence features 4 bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms, with every detail thoughtfully curated to maximize panoramic Island/Gulf views, comfort, and elegance. Offered FULLY FURNISHED with design by Clive Daniel Home’s Sherie Weidner, the interiors reflect a modern take on “coastal vacation,” incorporating light natural woods, glass, and stone to create a truly unique and sophisticated atmosphere. From the moment you step inside, the open-concept layout captivates with high-end finishes, vaulted ceilings, and seamless indoor-outdoor integration. Floor-to-ceiling windows and multiple balconies frame breathtaking Gulf vistas, while the state-of-the-art chef’s kitchen, complete with top-tier appliances, a spacious island, and custom cabinetry, is ideal for both entertaining and everyday living. The luxurious primary suite serves as a private sanctuary, featuring a spa-like bathroom, walk-in closets, and a serene balcony. A separate game room, a striking rock wall fireplace, and a stylish martini lounge add to the home’s standout design. Outdoor living is elevated with a covered lanai, resort-style pool with spa, and beach access across the street, creating the ultimate setting for relaxation. Smart home technology allows for effortless control of lighting, climate, and security, ensuring modern convenience. Hurricane-resistant construction, impact-resistant windows, reinforced structural elements, and elevated foundations, this home is designed to withstand Florida’s weather. Energy-efficient features, including high-efficiency HVAC systems and smart irrigation, enhance sustainability without compromising luxury. This stunning home is a rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise on Fort Myers Beach in one of the best residential locations on the island!

5921 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL Over $3,500,000

All Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Over $3,500,000

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?

Broker Brothers LLC

Search

Resources

About