Homes for Sale Between $1,250,000 to $1,500,000 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

185 Old San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

2026032895 MLS

Commercial Development Opportunity in the Heart of Fort Myers Beach As Fort Myers Beach continues its remarkable transformation, opportunities to own commercial property within the Downtown Core are becoming increasingly limited. With nearby commercial sites already moving into contract, available inventory along Old San Carlos Boulevard continues to shrink, making this an ideal time to secure a position in one of the island's most active redevelopment corridors. Located at 185 Old San Carlos Boulevard, this Commercial Boulevard (CB) zoned property presents an outstanding opportunity for investors, developers, and business owners alike. The existing structure provides the option to renovate and occupy in the near term, while the site's zoning and location create exceptional possibilities for future redevelopment. The property enjoys a highly visible location close to Times Square, the Fort Myers Beach Pier, Crescent Beach Family Park, Lynn Hall Memorial Park, and the Gulf of Mexico. Surrounded by restaurants, retail shops, entertainment venues, and popular tourist destinations, the area continues to attract increasing numbers of residents and visitors as redevelopment projects reshape the island. Ongoing public improvements, private investment, upgraded infrastructure, and new commercial development are helping redefine the Downtown Core into one of Southwest Florida's premier coastal destinations. This continued momentum offers significant long-term potential for businesses seeking to establish a presence in an expanding market. Commercial Boulevard zoning supports a broad range of permitted uses, including retail, restaurant, office, bar, hospitality, residential, and mixed-use projects. Whether your plans involve creating a destination dining experience, boutique retail space, professional offices, vacation accommodations, or a multi-level mixed-use development, this property offers the flexibility and location to bring those plans to reality while benefiting from the continued growth of Fort Myers Beach. Some Seller financing may be available.

185 Old San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$1,250,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026032636 MLS ⋅ Fort Myers Beach BLDG.

INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY in Fort Myers Beach's coveted WEEKLY RENTAL zone — welcome to The Turtle Nest, one of the island's most beloved and well-known vacation destinations. This is more than real estate — it's an established operation with a loyal following, glowing guest reviews, and bookings on the calendar. This turnkey 4-unit quad, offered fully furnished with vacation guests in place, can be purchased individually or together with its neighboring Turtle Nest properties — including an additional quadplex and a duplex on a double lot with a pool — giving a savvy investor the rare chance to own the complete 10-unit operation and continue the legacy. Just a short walk to the beach and the energy of Times Square, walkability keeps guests coming back year after year. The property has been thoughtfully hardened for island life: drywall replaced with cement board four feet up and removable screwed-in PVC trim throughout — smart, resilient construction built for long-term performance on a barrier island. Professionally managed and truly turnkey from day one, this is an income-producing property in one of the island's most consistent rental corridors. With Margaritaville anchoring Fort Myers Beach's remarkable revitalization and demand for weekly rentals outpacing supply, this is a rare chance to step into an operating island business guests already love. Sun, sand, and steady returns.

230 Fairweather Ln, Fort Myers Beach

$1,250,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026032637 MLS ⋅ Fort Myers Beach BLDG.

INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY in Fort Myers Beach's coveted WEEKLY RENTAL zone — part of The Turtle Nest, one of the island's most beloved and well-known vacation destinations. This turnkey 4-unit quad delivers the best of both worlds: two long-term month-to-month tenants in place providing steady income, and two units in the vacation rental program capturing the island's premium weekly rates. Purchase individually or together with the neighboring Turtle Nest properties — including an additional quadplex and a duplex on a double lot with a pool — for the rare opportunity to own the complete 10-unit operation, brand, and following. Just a short walk to the beach and Times Square, on a street where walkability drives repeat bookings season after season. Thoughtfully hardened for island life with cement board replacing drywall four feet up and removable screwed-in PVC trim — smart, resilient construction built for long-term performance on a barrier island. Professionally managed, fully furnished, and turnkey from day one. With Fort Myers Beach's revitalization accelerating around the new Margaritaville Resort, this is an income-producing island asset with built-in optionality — and a legacy ready for its next owner.

236 Fairweather Ln, Fort Myers Beach

$1,250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026032635 MLS ⋅ Fort Myers Beach BLDG.

INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY in Fort Myers Beach's coveted WEEKLY RENTAL zone — the crown jewel of The Turtle Nest, one of the island's most beloved and well-known vacation destinations. This turnkey duplex, featuring a 2-bedroom unit and a studio, sits on a rare DOUBLE LOT and boasts the only POOL in the portfolio — the amenity that anchors guest appeal and keeps the calendar full. Offered fully furnished with vacation guests in place, it can be purchased individually or together with the two neighboring Turtle Nest quads, giving a savvy investor the rare chance to own the complete 10-unit operation — an established island brand with a loyal following and years of growing bookings. Just a short walk to the beach and Times Square, where walkability brings guests back year after year. Thoughtfully hardened for island life with cement board replacing drywall four feet up and removable screwed-in PVC trim — smart, resilient construction built for long-term performance on a barrier island. The oversized double lot offers room to relax, entertain, and dream — a true outdoor oasis in the heart of the weekly rental district. Professionally managed and turnkey from day one, with Margaritaville anchoring the island's remarkable revitalization just up the road. Own the pool, own the lot, own the legacy.

228 Fairweather Ln, Fort Myers Beach

$1,449,000

226026705 MLS ⋅ Matanzas View BLDG.

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Exceptional Gulf-Access Waterfront Homesite with New Dock & Boat Lift – Prime Fort Myers Beach Location. Build a luxury 5-bedroom, elevated vacation home designed for today's rental market with the potential to generate $250,000+ in annual gross rental income (buyer to verify). Whether you're building for personal enjoyment, investment, or both, this location consistently attracts vacationers seeking the ultimate beach-and-boating experience. Located within a highly desirable weekly vacation rental zone, this property presents an outstanding opportunity. Build your dream coastal retreat or a high-performing investment property on this exceptional Gulf-access waterfront homesite in the heart of Fort Myers Beach. Situated on a deep, navigable canal with direct Gulf access and no bridges, this premier waterfront lot offers effortless boating with quick access to Estero Bay and the Gulf of Mexico. A brand-new dock spans the length of the seawall and is complemented by a new boat lift, providing immediate enjoyment while you plan your custom waterfront residence. The property also includes a fully operational swimming pool, a rare bonus that adds immediate value and flexibility. Perfectly positioned just minutes on foot to the sugar-sand beaches of the Gulf of America, you'll also enjoy an easy walk to Times Square, the Pier District, Margaritaville Resort, waterfront restaurants, shopping, and entertainment, allowing you to experience the very best of the Fort Myers Beach lifestyle. Multiple respected local builders are available to assist in designing and constructing your custom coastal home, making the building process seamless from concept to completion. Rare opportunities combining direct Gulf access, no bridges, a new dock and boat lift, a working pool, walkability to the beach, and proximity to Times Square are becoming increasingly difficult to find. Secure your piece of paradise and create the waterfront lifestyle you've always envisioned.

800 3rd St, Fort Myers Beach

4192 Bay Beach Ln Unit 875, Fort Myers Beach

$1,325,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 226026392 MLS ⋅ Waterside At Bay Beach BLDG.

From sunrise over Estero Bay to spectacular sunsets across the Gulf of Mexico, this extraordinary residence at Waterside at Bay Beach offers a waterfront lifestyle that few properties can match. Completely reimagined in 2021, this beautifully renovated three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath residence features an open-concept floor plan designed to maximize expansive water views while creating an elegant, light-filled living environment. Every detail reflects quality craftsmanship and timeless coastal sophistication. The beautifully renovated kitchen is the heart of the home, featuring elegant granite countertops, custom light gray cabinetry with convenient pull-out drawers, stainless steel appliances, a striking glass tile backsplash, custom lighting, and generous bar seating. Rich hardwood flooring throughout the living areas, complemented by tile in the wet areas, creates a warm yet sophisticated coastal ambiance. Wake each morning to breathtaking Gulf views from the breakfast room, then unwind on the expansive screened lanai as unforgettable Southwest Florida sunsets paint the sky. The private rear balcony overlooks picturesque Estero Bay, where dolphins, boats, and native wildlife create an ever-changing waterfront panorama. Few residences offer the rare privilege of enjoying both Gulf and Bay views from the comfort of home. Designed for beauty and peace of mind, the residence features impact-resistant openings, along with electric hurricane shutters on the lanai. A standout feature is the PRIVATE, climate-controlled, oversized Two-car garage with added additional storage—a rare luxury in waterfront condominium living that provides exceptional convenience, security, and value. Residents enjoy resort-style amenities including a waterfront pool, fitness center, sauna, tennis courts, bocce, fishing pier, two beautifully appointed guest suites, deeded beach access, and lush tropical landscaping. The community is pet friendly, and boat docks are available for purchase, providing convenient Gulf access for boating enthusiasts. This is more than a luxury condominium—it's an opportunity to experience the very best of Southwest Florida waterfront living. Rarely does a residence combine this level of renovation, exceptional amenities, and an unmatched waterfront lifestyle in one extraordinary offering.

4192 Bay Beach Ln Unit 875, Fort Myers Beach

$1,499,500

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 226025587 MLS ⋅ Fairview Isles BLDG.

STUNNING NEWLY REMODELED GULF-ACCESS CANAL HOME WITH POOL & DEEDED BEACH ACCESS & 20k BOAT LIFT! Experience luxury coastal living in this expansive 4-bedroom, 3-bath, 1,928 sq. ft. pool home ideally situated on a Gulf-access canal in the highly sought-after Fairview Isles community. Completely remodeled down to the studs, this open-concept residence showcases impeccable craftsmanship, high-end finishes, and modern coastal elegance throughout. The home features new plank tile flooring, a fully redesigned kitchen with new cabinetry, an oversized statement island, quartz countertops, and top-of-the-line appliances—perfect for entertaining and everyday living. A desirable split-bedroom floor plan offers both a Primary Suite and Junior Primary Suite, each with pool views and spa-inspired en-suite baths featuring designer tile and large walk-in showers. Outdoor living is exceptional with an expansive pool and deck area, ideal for entertaining, relaxing in the Florida sunshine, and enjoying tranquil canal views. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the newly upgraded boat lift with 20,000-lb motors, a private dock with brand-new Trex composite decking, and quick, direct access to the Gulf of Mexico. For added peace of mind, expandable flood barriers have been installed, offering a ready-to-use solution for door protection that can be quickly and easily deployed in advance of storm conditions. Additional highlights include a two-car garage, a spacious interior laundry room, and numerous recent upgrades throughout. Fairview Isles offers deeded beach access, just a short stroll to the sugar-sand beaches and dreamy sunsets of Fort Myers Beach. Ideally located on the south end of the island with convenient access to Naples, Bonita Springs, restaurants, golf courses, and RSW International Airport. This exceptional home delivers the ultimate boating and beach lifestyle, blending luxury, location, and peace of mind in one remarkable offering. Welcome home.

23 Palmview Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$1,499,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026027993 MLS ⋅ Santini Cross Unrec BLDG.

Fort Myers Beach is calling with the ultimate turnkey beach house, coastal chic remodel and fully equipped for effortless island living. While this beautiful home is special - the unexpected magic is the outdoor space. Set on a waterfront canal with quick access to Estero Bay and the Gulf of Mexico, this solid concrete home features a 23,000 lb boat lift with composite mooring deck, entertainment space with private silica sandy beach for campfires in the cool evenings or sunbathing, a wind down kayak launch and two racks, impact resistant windows/sliders and an expansive picture window screened lanai with custom Heyward lighting — perfect for entertaining and evening sunset. Outdoor living shines with a HUGE 8ft deep saltwater pool (equipment replaced 2025, recently resurfaced), sleek built in outdoor kitchen with $20K in appliance upgrades, commercial ice machine, mobile gas grill, and dining area, plus a huge fenced backyard for play and privacy. Fully permitted interiors were brought down to the studs then beautifully remodeled and complimented with Arhaus furnishings; all appliances replaced in 2025. Major systems updated: All new electrical wiring, plumbing, flooring, AC 2024, washer/dryer 2025 with full garage laundry and mini split cooling system, whole house water filtration system with instant hot water, including the wet bar with a garbage disposal and the metal roof replaced in 2021. This solid home has been meticulously improved with structure in mind adding a load bearing concrete beam to create an open, seamless living flow. Walk to the beach through to convenient access points or stroll to Santini Plaza Marina for great shops, restaurants, coffee, Ace Hardware and the UPS Store — a rare blend of coastal convenience and premium upgrades!

131 Egret St, Fort Myers Beach

$1,275,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026025498 MLS ⋅ Old Pelican Bay BLDG.

Welcome to 12205 Siesta Drive, the ultimate boating and fishing community located on an oversized southern exposure 1.5-lot parcel in the secure, gated enclave of Old Pelican Bay in Fort Myers Beach, the Boater & Fisherman's Paradise. With it's bonus rooms, the home offers over 2300 sq ft of living space under air. This property features one of the deepest, quickest Gulf-access canal locations in Southwest Florida with zero bridge restrictions. Fire up the engines and be in the Gulf in minutes, or head to the Keys and Bahamas. Walk down your private path and step onto your boat. Your private end-unit dock slip features a raised pedestal for dedicated electric and water, easily accommodating a deep-draft yacht up to 48 feet or a heavy-duty lift. Located on the naturally deep East canal, you will never face shallow water or expensive dredging bills. Built to support a marine lifestyle, this oversized 1.5-lot parcel offers plenty of room to add a custom pool and spa, with utility hookups in place. An enclosed, lockable storage shed comes equipped with a dedicated electrical subpanel—perfect for stashing rods, tackle, nets, and diving gear. Tough mechanical upgrades keep maintenance low, including a durable metal roof, private elevator, dual-zone AC, and a central vacuum system. Inside, find refined details including 9-foot ceilings, 3rd-floor cathedral ceilings, crown molding, plantation shutters, and gorgeous, rich maple cabinetry. Over $135k in upgrades and generous credits includes a huge $27,000 cash credit to the buyer at closing. This covers a brand-new appliance package ($6k), new flooring/carpet ($5k), and new 2nd-floor PGT hurricane windows ($16k). Combined with existing 3rd-floor impact glass and motorized storm shutters, the home is built like a fortress. Outside, beautiful Areca palms, Ficus hedges, and a custom 12V landscape lighting system create a magnificent private nighttime oasis. Spend your time on the water, not doing yard work. A weekly landscape crew handles all lawn cutting and edging. Low HOA fees ($429/month) cover your complete lawn care and the community's state-of-the-art security gate, complete with a license plate reader and contractor call-in office.

12205 Siesta Dr, Fort Myers Beach

$1,388,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226023442 MLS ⋅ Laguna Shores BLDG.

This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom island-style waterfront home sits on a generous ~10,237 sq ft lot in the desirable Laguna Shores neighborhood on the south end of Fort Myers Beach. It features a private pool with spacious outdoor entertaining areas. Fenced back yard great for dogs. New central air condition. Boat lift and dock on a navigable canal with seawall — enjoy quick 5–10 minute boat ride to open Gulf water or the bay. Partial Gulf views, canal views, intersecting canal, and mangrove vistas. 2-car garage plus ample parking in front, large enclosed storage space ground level under the house Modern comfortable living spaces ideal for relaxing or hosting. Perfect for families, boaters, and those seeking a pet-friendly retreat, this fully furnished-ready home blends comfort with coastal convenience. Whether you're watching dolphins from the deck, launching the boat for a sunset cruise, or strolling to nearby beaches, this property delivers the ultimate Fort Myers Beach lifestyle. Prime location in a waterfront community with easy access to world-class shelling, dining, and everything the island has to offer. A rare opportunity for waterfront living with pool and boat dock in a highly sought-after area.Ideal for your next Florida getaway, investment, or full-time coastal residence.

116 Sand Dollar Dr, Fort Myers Beach

$1,450,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 2026026739 MLS ⋅ Watson W W BLDG.

Welcome to Pink Flamingo, a charming Key West-style retreat where boating, beach days, and island living come together in one exceptional Fort Myers Beach location. This beautifully appointed 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence offers multiple levels of coastal comfort, complete with an assigned boat slip providing direct access to Estero Bay and the Gulf of Mexico. Inside, you'll find an inviting blend of style and functionality featuring tile flooring, a private elevator, crown molding, plantation shutters, and coastal-inspired finishes throughout. The spacious kitchen is designed for gathering and entertaining, showcasing quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, custom cabinetry, a center island, breakfast nook, wet bar with beverage center, and a generous walk-in pantry. Enjoy the outdoors from multiple private balconies where tropical breezes and bay views create the perfect backdrop for morning coffee or evening cocktails. Additional features include a multi-car garage, community pool with cabana, and convenient beach access located at the end of Delmar Avenue—allowing you to enjoy both sunrise boating adventures and sunset walks along the Gulf. Ideally situated near Times Square, Bay Oaks Recreational Center, local restaurants, shops, entertainment, and the sugar-sand beaches of Fort Myers Beach, Pink Flamingo offers an outstanding opportunity as a primary residence, vacation getaway, or investment property in one of Southwest Florida's most desirable island communities.

276 Delmar Ave, Fort Myers Beach

$1,450,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 2026026745 MLS ⋅ Watson W W BLDG.

Welcome to Blue Dolphin, an exceptional Key West-inspired residence perfectly positioned in the heart of Fort Myers Beach. This impressive multi-level home offers 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and an inviting blend of coastal elegance and island charm, complete with an assigned boat slip for effortless access to Estero Bay and the Gulf waters beyond. Designed for comfortable living and entertaining, the interior showcases tile flooring throughout, a private elevator, crown molding, plantation shutters, and thoughtfully curated coastal finishes. The gourmet kitchen serves as the heart of the home, featuring stainless steel appliances, quartz countertops, a center island, custom cabinetry, breakfast nook, wet bar with beverage center, and a spacious walk-in pantry. Outdoor living takes center stage with multiple balconies capturing beautiful bay views and refreshing island breezes. Additional highlights include a multi-car garage, community pool and cabana, and deeded beach access located at the end of Delmar Avenue—offering the best of both boating and beachside living. Ideally situated just moments from Times Square, Bay Oaks Recreational Center, the public library, waterfront dining, shopping, entertainment, and the white-sand beaches that make Fort Myers Beach a sought-after destination. Whether as a primary residence, seasonal retreat, or investment property, Blue Dolphin presents an exceptional opportunity to embrace the ultimate Southwest Florida waterfront lifestyle.

282 Delmar Ave, Fort Myers Beach

Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL Between $1,250,000 to $1,500,000

All Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $1,250,000 to $1,500,000

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?

Broker Brothers LLC

Search

Resources

About