Explore Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $1,250,000 to $1,500,000

Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $1,250,000 to $1,500,000 Map Search

Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL Between $1,250,000 to $1,500,000

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Welcome to your dedicated resource for Homes for Sale Between $1,250,000 to $1,500,000 in Fort Myers Beach, FL. This page is your live portal for listings that match the exact homes for sale you demand, filtering out irrelevant properties to save you time. As a local Fort Myers Beach, FL agent, Broker Brothers specializes in the unique market dynamics of this area, offering insights into amenities, home values, and investment potential. Start exploring the properties currently available between $1,250,000 to $1,500,000 below, or contact a local agent to discuss the details that matters most to your search.

< Back to all Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Search Fort Myers Beach, FL by Price

All Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $1,250,000 to $1,500,000

$1,299,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226001200 MLS ⋅ Laguna Shores BLDG.
Charming coastal retreat ideally located on the south end of Fort Myers Beach, situated on a corner lot directly across the street from the beach, offering easy access to the sugar-sand shoreline. Weekly rentals allowed. Located in the highly desirable Laguna Shores neighborhood, this raised single-family home offers 1,350 sq. ft. of living space with an ideal indoor-outdoor floor plan. The open-concept living, dining, and kitchen areas are filled with natural light from large windows and a set of sliding glass doors that enhance indoor-outdoor living. The kitchen is centered around a large granite-topped island and features stainless steel appliances, including a gas range and Bosch dishwasher, ample cabinetry with soft-close drawers and doors, and generous counter space. Both bedrooms are spacious and comfortably accommodate king-size beds. The owner’s suite features a private en-suite bath, complemented by a well-appointed guest bedroom and second full bath, creating a functional and inviting layout for everyday living or hosting guests. A wrap-around upper porch spans two sides of the home, creating an inviting space for outdoor living and entertaining, with a convenient pass-through from the kitchen for outdoor dining. Outdoor living is enhanced by a sparkling private pool, along with a ground-level covered patio. A large 2+ car garage provides ample space for beach gear, bicycles, and storage. Deeded beach access adds to the appeal. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, and island amenities, with quick access to Bonita Springs, Naples, and the airport, this home offers an exceptional beachside lifestyle with flexibility and convenience.

170 Redfish Rd, Fort Myers Beach
$1,350,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2025020603 MLS ⋅ Fort Myers Beach BLDG.
Stunning Income-Producing 4-Plex on Fort Myers Beach Discover an exceptional investment opportunity just steps from the white-sand shoreline of Fort Myers Beach. This 4-unit multifamily property offers the perfect blend of island living and strong rental performance. Each unit is thoughtfully designed to maximize comfort, natural light, and functionality, appealing to both long-term residents and short-term vacation tenants. This property was completely remodeled and completed in late 2025, is located on a street that allows weekly rentals which means 1 guest per week, no matter how long the reservation! The property features updated interiors, modern kitchens, and well-maintained bathrooms, with ample parking and private outdoor space for tenants to relax and enjoy coastal breezes. Located in a highly desirable area close to restaurants, shops, marinas, live entertainment, and the future redeveloped Times Square district, this 4-plex sits in one of the most in-demand rental corridors on the island. Whether you're expanding your portfolio or searching for a reliable cash-flowing asset, this property checks all the boxes—location, income potential, and long-term appreciation. With rental demand on the rise and limited inventory available, opportunities like this don’t come around often.

113-119 Fairweather Ln, Fort Myers Beach
$1,275,000
2025018091 MLS
NOW IS YOUR TIME TO INVEST IN FORT MYERS BEACH! INVEST IN THE FUTURE OF WHAT IT WILL BE 5-10 YEARS FROM NOW! If you’ve been looking for a waterfront commercial property with Gulf access in an unbeatable location, this is one of those rare finds that doesn’t come along often. Positioned directly on San Carlos Boulevard just about a mile from downtown Fort Myers Beach, this bayfront property sits right in the center of Southwest Florida’s busiest marine and tourism hub. With exceptional visibility, steady traffic flow, and direct access to open water, this location works for your business day in and day out. You’re surrounded by well-established, high-performing businesses including fishing charters, boat rentals, parasailing companies, tiki tours, and other marine-focused operations. The demand is already here - this is where customers naturally come for waterfront experiences. Add in walkability to popular restaurants and bars, and you have a consistent stream of both foot traffic and boat traffic from locals and visitors alike. A major advantage of this property is that the submerged land is owned rather than leased, an increasingly rare and valuable feature. This provides long-term control, flexibility, and peace of mind without the limitations or uncertainty that can come with lease agreements. There’s also an existing large dock already in place, allowing you to get up and running quickly. Located in Pelican Bay, the property offers fast, deep-water access with no extended idle zones, so you can reach the Gulf of America within minutes. Whether you're envisioning a marina, charter fishing business, boat tour company, eco-tourism venture, water taxi service, marine service operation, or a combination, the setup here supports it all. This is a true Fort Myers Beach waterfront commercial opportunity with the visibility, access, and infrastructure already in place. With redevelopment continuing and growth accelerating in the area, properties like this are becoming harder to find. If you’ve been waiting for the right bayfront commercial property near the heart of Fort Myers Beach, complete with Gulf access, owned submerged land, and a prime San Carlos Boulevard location, this is your chance to secure it before it’s gone.

18850 San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$1,399,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ 225071251 MLS ⋅ Gulf View Plaza BLDG.
Rarely available on Fort Myers Beach! This elevated home on an oversized lot delivers the ultimate coastal lifestyle with direct Gulf beach access and private bay access with a fishing pier—a true one-of-a-kind opportunity. Enjoy a bright, open floor plan built for entertaining, a heated pool, and expansive outdoor living areas surrounded by tropical landscaping for shade, privacy, and relaxation. The entire ground level serves as a lounge and play area, adding even more space for family and guests. Whether you’re swimming laps, hosting gatherings, or simply unwinding in your backyard oasis, this home is designed for enjoyment. With unbeatable location, dual water access, and exceptional rental potential, this property is perfect as a luxury residence, vacation retreat, or high-performing income investment.

167 Coconut Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$1,450,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 2025008643 MLS ⋅ Indian Bayou Subd BLDG.
Condominium UNIT B in Indian Bayou offering nearly 3,000 sq ft of living space with 3BR/3BA, soaring ceilings, and an open floor plan designed for coastal living. Enjoy bay views from the screened balcony, a rare 4-car garage, and quality block construction with a metal roof. This is a 55+ community.

21523 Indian Bayou Dr, Fort Myers Beach
$1,500,000
225054138 MLS ⋅ Fort Myers Beach BLDG.
Waterfront Opportunity on the North End of Fort Myers Beach Discover a rare canal-front lot in one of Fort Myers Beach’s most peaceful and sought-after neighborhoods. Previously home to a 4-unit building, this property offers the flexibility to rebuild as a fourplex or design your dream single-family home. Set among newly built single-family residences, this location combines tranquility with convenience—just a 3-minute stroll to the vibrant energy of Times Square, where you’ll find popular spots like Mr. Waves Island Bar and more. Enjoy direct canal access leading straight into the bay—ideal for boating and waterfront living. An existing pool from the original structure still remains on-site and may offer restoration potential.

151 Matanzas St, Fort Myers Beach
$1,500,000
225028955 MLS ⋅ Grand Ole Man BLDG.
Don't miss out on this opportunity! Discover a rare opportunity to own a slice of paradise on the highly desirable South end of Fort Myers Beach! This spacious vacant lot offers the perfect canvas to build your dream beach home or investment property. Nestled in a vibrant coastal community, this property is just steps away from the sugar-white sands and clear blue waters of the Gulf of America! Located in a weekly rental zone, 7 day rental minimum, 52 rentals a year, opportunity is there for investment income! Buy your future lot now to join the future development going on at Fort Myers Beach! New Pass Bridge is completed with a new higher 4 lane bridge, Sanitni Plaza is now open, NEW Fort Myers Beach Pier Installation in 2027, Margaritaville is fully up and running, and many other future developments are in the works along the beach!

7902 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$1,299,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 224074114 MLS ⋅ Watsons C S Add BLDG.
LIVING THE ISLAND DREAM: 2023 BUILT, MODERN ELEVATED OASIS STEPS FROM THE GULF. Welcome to your personal paradise on the coveted North End of Fort Myers Beach! Designed for effortless living and maximum peace of mind, this modern 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom resort-style home is built to the latest storm and wind codes, elevated well above flood lines, and packed with coastal charm. The Highlights: • Unbeatable Location: Just ~300 meters to the soft sands of the Gulf of Mexico and under 200 meters to the wide-open Bay and marina. • Outdoor Living: Enjoy golden hour with northwest rear exposure, relax under the palms, or take a dip in your private heated pool. • Walkable Paradise: Stroll to Times Square, the iconic Pier, and Margaritaville. Catch a breathtaking sunset on the beach, enjoy a world-class dinner, and grab a nightcap with live music on your easy walk back home. • Smart Layout: Designed with a bright, open floor plan that effortlessly flows from indoor relaxing to poolside lounging. Whether you're looking for a personal sanctuary, a "play-and-rent" retreat, or a turn-key asset, this property sits in the coveted Weekly Rental Zone and is 1031-exchange ready. Your tropical wonderland awaits—schedule your private tour today

233 Delmar Ave, Fort Myers Beach
$1,435,000
223036603 MLS ⋅ Sanibel Seafood BLDG.
LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! Less than a half a mile to the Ft Myers Beach bridge. This property offers great beach and land access! Being on the San Carlos island offers great convenience and easier access to Ft Myers than Estero Island. The Property has great potential! 1.160 acres, zoned C-2. over 7000 sq’ concrete block building. This property was the home of The Sanibel Seafood Company since 1982. A successful wholesale and retail seafood distribution company. A high growth area less than a mile to the new Margaritaville Resort and theNew Beached Whale on Ft Myers Beach. Seller’s would consider a land contract to purchase. Zoning in the area is fluid, per Lee County. The property is made up of three losts with multiple zoning classifications. Lee County has been very helpful and will confirm it if the property fits your intended use. There are great things happening in the rebuilding of Ft Myers beach, this is your opportunity to be a part of the ground floor development. Please call to schedule a showing or for additional information. Information is deemed correct, but not guaranteed.

870 Buttonwood Dr, Fort Myers Beach
Start Your Search