Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 226032430 MLS ⋅ Grand Ole Man BLDG.

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. BUY THE BEACH NOW. ENJOY IT TODAY. DREAM BIG FOR TOMORROW. Set directly on the sugar-white sands of Fort Myers Beach, this distinctive south-end Gulf-front property presents an exciting opportunity for beach lovers, investors, and buyers who understand the long-term value of owning irreplaceable beachfront land. Situated on an impressive 80-foot-wide beachfront lot, the property combines immediate enjoyment and income potential with an extraordinary canvas for the future. Keep the existing elevated residence and enjoy an effortless beach retreat from day one, continue operating it as an income-producing vacation property, explore opportunities to expand the outdoor living experience with a pool, or begin imagining a future custom Gulf-front estate tailored entirely to your vision. Any future improvements, expansion, pool installation, or redevelopment are subject to applicable zoning, setbacks, permitting, and governmental approvals. The existing home is anything but ordinary. Its distinctive octagonal architectural design creates character throughout while capturing Gulf views, natural light, coastal breezes, and spectacular sunsets from multiple vantage points. Elevated construction adds another layer of appeal for coastal ownership. Inside, the home offers 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, plus a generous loft with additional sleeping accommodations, providing flexibility for family, friends, and vacation guests. The layout feels relaxed and unmistakably beach-oriented—the kind of property where shoes come off, doors open, and the Gulf becomes part of everyday life. For investors, the opportunity is equally compelling. The home is currently operating as an income-generating property, allowing a new owner to step into an established beachfront asset while considering longer-term plans for the site. Rather than purchasing vacant beachfront land and waiting to create value, this property offers the ability to own, enjoy, and potentially generate income now while planning for what comes next. And then there is the location. Positioned on the coveted south end of Fort Myers Beach, you’ll enjoy a quieter, more residential atmosphere while remaining convenient to island dining and shopping, Bonita Springs, Naples, and Southwest Florida International Airport. Whether your vision is a turnkey beach escape, vacation-rental investment, enhanced coastal retreat with a pool, or the future site of your dream beachfront residence, this is the kind of opportunity that is increasingly difficult to replicate. 85 feet of Gulf frontage. An existing income-producing home. Direct access to the sand. And a future limited only by your imagination.

8246 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$2,890,000

226031400 MLS ⋅ Hyde Park BLDG.

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Located directly on the sand in the heart of Fort Myers Beach, this is the kind of setting people search a lifetime for. Imagine mornings with the Gulf breeze rolling in, afternoons on the beach just steps from your door, and evenings watching the sky transform into a living canvas of gold, pink, and blue as the sun sinks into the water, a different masterpiece every night. Shaded by mature palm trees and framed by open Gulf views, this is a place to build the coastal life you’ve been dreaming about, whether that’s a custom retreat, a seasonal getaway, or a smart investment in one of Florida’s most in-demand rental markets. This .20-acre (8,668 sq ft) beachfront lot is zoned RS-1 with SW rear exposure and sits within the weekly vacation rental zone, offering flexibility for residential or investment use. Just minutes from the island’s best shopping, dining, and entertainment, opportunities like this on Estero Blvd don’t come around often.

4330 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

5575 Avenida Pescadora, Fort Myers Beach

$2,825,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 226031269 MLS ⋅ Holiday Heights BLDG.

WATERFRONT PARADISE! Magnificent luxury custom-built home situated on a wide Gulf-access canal with direct access to picturesque Estero Bay. Built by Gary Lau, this exceptional residence offers approximately 2,600 sq. ft. under air, featuring 3 bedrooms plus a den, 3 luxurious bathrooms, and an abundance of ground-level open space ideal for storage, recreation, entertaining, and more. An elevator provides effortless access to every level, blending convenience with sophisticated coastal living. The expansive great room features soaring ceilings and opens seamlessly to your private outdoor oasis. A spectacular two-story screened pool enclosure surrounds the inviting saltwater pool and spa, creating the perfect setting for relaxing, entertaining, and enjoying the year-round Florida lifestyle. BOATER'S DREAM LOCATION! Step outside to your impressive 16,000-lb. boat lift and dock, where endless aquatic adventures await. With direct Gulf access, you can enjoy boating, fishing, sunset cruises, and easy access to the beautiful waters of Estero Bay and beyond. Wake up to tranquil waterfront views and spend your days exploring Southwest Florida by boat. For the car enthusiast, boater, or outdoor lifestyle enthusiast, this property delivers with an oversized four-car garage, additional storage, and an RV electrical hookup. Every detail of this custom residence reflects quality craftsmanship, thoughtful design, and a commitment to luxury waterfront living. Ideally located within walking distance to the marina, restaurants, bars, shops, and more, this home offers the perfect combination of privacy and convenience. Enjoy easy access to the south end of Fort Myers Beach via Lovers Key, with convenient boating and driving access toward Bonita Springs, Naples, and Southwest Florida's renowned dining and entertainment destinations. From the lush surroundings and breathtaking water views to the resort-style pool, exceptional dockage, elevator, and generous garage space, this magnificent custom home offers an unparalleled waterfront lifestyle. Experience the ultimate blend of luxury, comfort, boating, and waterfront bliss. Welcome home.

5575 Avenida Pescadora, Fort Myers Beach

$2,875,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 226031146 MLS ⋅ Hyde Park BLDG.

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Welcome to 205 Bayview Avenue, a rare bayfront pool home on Fort Myers Beach where exceptional waterfront living, an expansive homesite, and strong rental potential come together in one remarkable property. Set on a generously sized lot with wide bay views, this renovated residence offers a sense of space and privacy that is increasingly difficult to find on the island. The waterfront setting is the true centerpiece, with peaceful views across the bay and frequent sightings of dolphins, manatees, and coastal wildlife just beyond the shoreline. Inside, the home has been thoughtfully updated on both levels and features three bedrooms plus a den and three full bathrooms. The flexible layout lends itself beautifully to full-time living, a second home, or vacation rental use. The upper level includes a chef’s kitchen and full bar designed for entertaining, while the lower level offers a separate kitchenette for added versatility and guest accommodations. The home is located on a direct beach access street, allowing you to enjoy both bayfront and beachside living with ease. Just one block north of Publix and close to mid-island dining, shopping, and entertainment, the location offers outstanding convenience without sacrificing the quiet residential atmosphere. With its substantial lot size, bay frontage, renovated interior, flexible floor plan, and prime mid-island location, 205 Bayview Avenue presents an exceptional opportunity for buyers seeking space, waterfront lifestyle, and long-term value on Fort Myers Beach. Whether envisioned as a private island retreat, income-producing vacation property, or future waterfront estate, this is a property with remarkable versatility and potential.

205 Bayview Ave, Fort Myers Beach

$3,399,000

226031158 MLS ⋅ San Carlos On The Gulf BLDG.

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Set along the bayfront of San Carlos Island, 948 San Carlos Boulevard presents an exceptional opportunity to create a custom waterfront estate on a remarkably spacious homesite. Encompassing approximately 20,830 square feet, with 100 feet of direct bay frontage and a depth of roughly 215 feet, the property offers an impressive sense of scale, privacy, and design flexibility. Western exposure provides a front-row seat to spectacular Southwest Florida sunsets, while the adjacent deep-water canal offers quick access to the Gulf of Mexico. A newer dock is already in place and designed to accommodate two boat lifts, creating immediate boating access while plans for a future residence take shape. The generous dimensions of the property allow for expansive indoor-outdoor living, substantial outdoor entertaining areas, resort-style amenities, and a residence designed to fully embrace the surrounding water views. San Carlos Island continues to evolve as an increasingly desirable waterfront destination, offering close proximity to Fort Myers Beach while maintaining convenient access on and off the island. Waterfront dining, the beaches of Fort Myers Beach, Margaritaville Resort, and local entertainment are all just minutes away, with easy connections to Sanibel, Captiva, Bonita Springs, Naples, and Southwest Florida International Airport. With no rental restrictions, the property also offers flexibility for those considering a luxury vacation residence or investment opportunity. Combining a rare half-acre setting, expansive bay frontage, deep-water Gulf access, western exposure, and an outstanding location, 948 San Carlos Boulevard is an exceptional canvas for a distinctive Southwest Florida waterfront home.

948 San Carlos Dr, Fort Myers Beach

$3,500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 226027621 MLS ⋅ Key West Courtyards BLDG.

Experience elevated coastal living in this exceptional two-story beach home, ideally situated just steps from the sugar-white sands and Gulf waters of Fort Myers Beach. Located in a desirable weekly rental area, the property offers the flexibility to enjoy as a private beach retreat while also providing excellent rental potential. Beautifully appointed and filled with natural light, the residence combines refined finishes, generous living spaces, and gorgeous Gulf views with an effortless indoor-outdoor lifestyle. The open-concept main living area features a well-equipped kitchen with stainless steel appliances that flows seamlessly into the dining and living spaces. Multiple Gulf-view balconies extend the living area outdoors, providing inviting spaces for morning coffee, alfresco dining, and spectacular sunset views. The spacious primary suite is a private retreat featuring a king-sized bedroom, wet bar, luxurious Jacuzzi tub, and an expansive private balcony overlooking the Gulf. An additional generously sized guest bedroom with its own en-suite bath provides comfort and privacy for family and guests. Additional features include a full laundry room, ample storage, and quality finishes throughout. Residents also enjoy a heated community pool shared exclusively by the four homes within the intimate Key West Court enclave. The location offers exceptional convenience, with Publix, a nearby marina, restaurants, shopping, and the Fort Myers Beach trolley all within walking distance. Whether enjoyed as a full-time residence, seasonal retreat, or income-producing investment, this distinctive beach home delivers an exceptional combination of Gulf views, rental flexibility, privacy, convenience, and the relaxed coastal lifestyle that makes Fort Myers Beach so desirable.

260 Key West Ct, Fort Myers Beach

$3,495,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4.5 Baths ⋅ 226027475 MLS ⋅ Grand Ole Man BLDG.

Beautifully renovated direct beachfront home on South Estero Island with breathtaking Gulf views! Sits on a rare stretch of beach with an ultra-private backyard with no passersby to be seen, providing optimal privacy. This 4 bed/4.5 coastal delight has been completely remodeled and features a newer metal roof, Generac whole house generator (2021), 2 new HVACS (2020), new instant water heater (2020), hurricane impact windows/sliders throughout, and new interior staircase. Step outside onto your open-air wraparound balcony and enjoy endless views of the turquoise waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Stunning chef’s kitchen contributes to the wide-open floor plan and offers custom-built white cabinetry, gorgeous white quartz countertops, waterfall island, walk-in pantry, and new high-end Jenn-Air appliances (2020) including double ovens and induction cooktop. The spacious primary bedroom is a tranquil haven with floor to ceiling windows/slider to fully indulge in the Gulf views and has a spa-like bath with dual vanities, large jetted soaking tub, and separate walk-in shower with multiple shower heads. The top floor is perfect for a private guest wing or an extra bonus room with an ensuite bathroom and top floor sun deck for picture-perfect sunsets over the Gulf. Just steps from the beach, your outdoor oasis awaits — featuring a fenced-in heated saltwater pool and spa, along with a brand-new summer kitchen ideal for poolside dining and sunset entertaining. Other features include a Lutron lighting system, Savant sound system upstairs, tile flooring, and coffered ceiling details. This is a fantastic vacation home or investment opportunity located in a weekly rental zone allowing for maximum rental income if desired! Perfectly situated on the coveted South-end of Estero Island near Lovers Key, Bonita Beach & the South bridge to the mainland with dining and shopping walking distance.

8124 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$2,799,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 226026921 MLS ⋅ Cases BLDG.

2021-built Luxury POOL home featuring 6-bedroom + 6-bathrooms, Elevator, Sunset Decks and Gulf Views. Deeded beach access across the Street. Perfect for Personal use, blended use or as a high gross income STR with a potential of $250,000+. Designed to accommodate up to 14 guests, this turnkey coastal retreat has the layout, location, and amenities today's luxury owners are actively seeking. Spanning three stories with a private elevator, the home features an impressive observation level showcasing panoramic Gulf-to-Island views, creating an unforgettable guest experience that drives premium rental demand. The open-concept great room is designed for entertaining, featuring plank tile flooring throughout, coastal-inspired finishes, soaring ceilings, crown molding, and walls of impact-rated sliding glass doors that fill the home with natural light and spectacular beach views. The chef's kitchen offers white shaker cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and an oversized center island with generous seating—ideal for large family gatherings and vacation groups. Most bedrooms are private en-suites, including dual primary suites, providing exceptional comfort and privacy for multiple families traveling together. Perfectly positioned overlooking the Gulf of Mexico with deeded beach access directly across the street, guests can enjoy effortless days on the sand, unforgettable sunsets, and the ultimate Southwest Florida vacation experience. Outside, guests will love relaxing in the heated resort-style pool, enjoying the expansive brick paver patio, and walking directly to the beach in just moments. Two oversized garages provide abundant storage for vehicles, golf carts, beach equipment, and owner supplies. Built with longevity and peace of mind in mind, this home features a driven piling foundation engineered for 170+ mph winds, impact-resistant windows and doors, and remained high and dry with no flooding in the living areas through multiple hurricanes. Whether you're looking to maximize vacation rental revenue, complete a 1031 exchange, or own an exceptional second home that generates substantial income while you're away, this property offers an outstanding combination of luxury, location, durability, and investment performance in the heart of Fort Myers Beach.

3749 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$2,699,000

2026032210 MLS ⋅ Winklers Subdivision BLDG.

Build your dream home on this Fort Myers Beach GULF FRONT LOT with UNENDING PANAORMAIC VIEWS of the Gulf of Mexico! Nicely located mid-island in a quiet area of Fort Myers Beach. Don't miss this opportunity to own one of the nicest GULF FRONT lots available!

53 Pompano St, Fort Myers Beach

$2,500,000

226026661 MLS ⋅ Grand Ole Man BLDG.

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Rare Gulf-Front Vacant Land Opportunity. Build your dream beachfront estate on one of the most desirable Gulf-front homesites on Fort Myers Beach. Situated directly on the sugar-sand beaches of the Gulf of Mexico, this exceptional waterfront lot offers breathtaking panoramic sunsets, unobstructed Gulf views, and endless possibilities for luxury coastal living. Located on the peaceful south end of Estero Island, this oversized approximately 0.38-acre homesite provides approximately 71 feet of direct Gulf frontage and is perfectly positioned near Lovers Key, Bonita Beach, world-class dining, boating, and shopping. Property information indicates the lot is zoned RS-1 and is located in an area that permits weekly vacation rentals, creating an outstanding opportunity for both personal enjoyment and investment potential. Highlights include: Direct Gulf-front waterfront location, Approximately 0.38-acre homesite, Spectacular sunset and beach views, Ideal for a custom luxury residence. SAMPLE NEW CONSTRUCTION HOME RENDERINGS IN PHOTOS ARE NOT INCLUDED IN SALE PRICE OF THE LOT. Weekly rental potential for HIGH GROSS income opportunities, Utilities available Easy access to Lovers Key, Bonita Beach, and Southwest Florida International Airport Whether you're envisioning a private coastal retreat or a high-performing vacation rental investment, this is a rare opportunity to own one of Fort Myers Beach's premier beachfront parcels.

8030 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

$2,575,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 225080635 MLS ⋅ Cases BLDG.

NEW CONSTRUCTION UNDERWAY ON FORT MYERS BEACH – SECURE YOUR DREAM COASTAL HOME TODAY! Construction has officially begun, with exciting progress being made! Now is the perfect opportunity to secure your dream coastal home with a deposit and pay the remaining balance upon completion, anticipated in 2027! Welcome to luxurious, modern coastal living on Fort Myers Beach! This exceptional new construction residence offers 4 spacious bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, and approximately 3,300 square feet of beautifully designed living space, combining sophisticated finishes with the relaxed elegance of island living. Designed for both comfort and entertaining, the home features an expansive open-concept great room, a chef-inspired kitchen, luxurious bathrooms, and premium finishes throughout. Two oversized northwest-facing decks provide the perfect setting to enjoy breathtaking sunsets and refreshing Gulf breezes. Step outside to your own private tropical paradise, complete with a resort-style pool and spa featuring a sun shelf, ideal for relaxing and entertaining. BUY NOW, PERSONALIZE YOUR HOME, AND WATCH IT COME TO LIFE! Secure your property during construction, receive regular progress updates from the builder, and enjoy the opportunity to customize select finishes, colors, and design details to your personal taste, subject to construction progress and builder approval. The remaining purchase price is due at closing following completion and issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy, anticipated in 2027. Perfectly situated in a desirable mid-island location, just steps from the sugar-white sandy beaches, this property offers WEEKLY RENTAL FLEXIBILITY, making it an outstanding opportunity for a primary residence, luxury vacation retreat, or income-producing investment. WHY WAIT UNTIL 2027? SECURE YOUR PIECE OF PARADISE TODAY! Experience the best of Fort Myers Beach living with modern luxury, exceptional outdoor spaces, and incredible investment potential!

101 Anchorage St, Fort Myers Beach

$2,500,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 2026024527 MLS ⋅ Gulf Heights BLDG.

Experience the ultimate Southwest Florida beach lifestyle in this stunning newer-construction Fort Myers Beach residence, perfectly positioned just steps from the sugar-sand shores of the Gulf with deeded beach access directly across the street. This exceptional 5-bedroom, 5-bathroom home offers luxury, comfort, and investment potential as a highly successful vacation rental ($250K+ in 2026) with future bookings already in place. Designed with both entertaining and relaxation in mind, four of the five bedrooms serve as spacious primary suites, each featuring walk-in closets and private en-suite bathrooms. An elevator provides access to all three levels, while travertine flooring flows throughout the home. The third-floor great room is the heart of the home, showcasing breathtaking Gulf views and opening to an oversized balcony where you can enjoy sunsets and coastal breezes. The thoughtfully designed floor plan also includes a game room, creating endless opportunities for family fun and guest entertainment. Step outside to your private tropical oasis featuring a resort-style pool and spa, complemented by a unique outdoor poolside projector for unforgettable movie nights. Offered fully turnkey, this property is ready for immediate enjoyment or continued rental success. Whether you're seeking a luxury beach retreat, an income-producing investment property, or both, this extraordinary Fort Myers Beach home delivers an unparalleled coastal living experience.

5335 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach

Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

All Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?

Broker Brothers LLC

Search

Resources

About