Explore Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000 Map Search

Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Welcome to your dedicated resource for Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000 in Fort Myers Beach, FL. This page is your live portal for listings that match the exact homes for sale you demand, filtering out irrelevant properties to save you time. As a local Fort Myers Beach, FL agent, Broker Brothers specializes in the unique market dynamics of this area, offering insights into amenities, home values, and investment potential. Start exploring the properties currently available between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000 below, or contact a local agent to discuss the details that matters most to your search.

< Back to all Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Search Fort Myers Beach, FL by Price

All Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale Between $2,500,000 to $3,500,000

$3,059,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 226010110 MLS ⋅ Waterside At Bay Beach BLDG.
IMMEDIATE OCCUPANCY! One of London Bay's remaining residences in the newest and final tower in the gated community of Waterside at Bay Beach Lane. The wait is over for new construction on Fort Myers Beach/Estero Island, Florida's "Gold Coast". Enjoy this limited opportunity to be part of Grandview at Bay Beach, on the southern tip of Estero Island, just a stone's throw from Lover's Key, nestled between Fort Myers & Bonita Springs/Naples, where days begin with glorious sunrises, are spent leisurely shelling, beaching and boating, and end with amazing sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico. Grandview at Bay Beach is the ONLY new construction tower with WALKABILITY to the beach. Grandview is within walking distance to shopping, restaurants, a full-service marina, and in close proximity to RSW airport. This is truly a unique opportunity with limited residences available! Welcome to elevated waterfront living on Estero Island at Grandview. CONTACT US TODAY FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF REMAINING RESIDENCES!

4142 Bay Beach Ln Unit 901, Fort Myers Beach
$3,500,000
2026012341 MLS ⋅ Fort Myers Beach BLDG.
Commercial - Multi use property, zoned Downtown within the City limits of Ft. Myers Beach. This vacant corner is located just 5 blocks east of Margaritaville and Times Square.

1801 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,699,000
2026011222 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
Introducing an exceptional direct bayfront lot on the prestigious north end of Fort Myers Beach — an area now transforming with a collection of newly built ultra-luxury estates that are redefining the island’s skyline. This rare parcel offers a premier opportunity to design a signature residence or duplex in one of the most coveted waterfront corridors on the island. Set along the shimmering expanse of Estero Bay, the property delivers unobstructed panoramic water views, daily marine life activity, and effortless Gulf access from your future private dock. The white sands of Fort Myers Beach lie just across the street, creating a true dual-waterfront lifestyle — beach out front, boating out back. Zoned for either a single-family home or duplex and located within a short-term rental district, this lot offers exceptional flexibility for luxury living, high-end rental income, or a combination of both. With no HOA or club fees, owners retain full control over design, use, and long-term value. Surrounded by a growing enclave of multimillion-dollar custom homes, this property stands as a premier canvas for a showpiece build. Its 53-year legacy of single-family ownership underscores the rarity and desirability of this location — a place where memories have been made for decades and where a new owner can now create an extraordinary coastal retreat. A direct bayfront lot in a rapidly elevating luxury neighborhood, with beach access steps away and Gulf boating at your back door, represents one of the strongest long-term investment plays on Fort Myers Beach

507 Carlos Cir, Fort Myers Beach
$2,500,000
2026007581 MLS ⋅ Grand Ole Man BLDG.
EXCEPTIONAL BEACH FRONT PROPERTY zoned single family on the expansive southern end of Estero Island, where new construction of luxury homes is ongoing. Prestigious south end location. Quiet and Peaceful spot on the beach to build your dream luxury residence. Nothing will be between you and the sunset! This property extends to the glistening Gulf waters, extra deep lot, secluded & private sandy beach at your doorstep! Close to Santini Plaza with convenient access to Bonita Beach and Naples via Big Carlos Pass within a short drive. Over the bridge on Lovers Key you'll find Flipper's-on-the-Bay for fine dining, as well as the state park for kayaking, shelling, beaches and nature tours. This is one of the nicest beachfront lots for sale in the area, don't miss out!

7986 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,500,000
2026002686 MLS ⋅ Cresent Beach Plaza BLDG.
Prime Mixed-Use Opportunity Steps from the Gulf – Rare Fort Myers Beach Development Site – Welcome to a truly exceptional opportunity just one parcel off the Gulf in the heart of Fort Myers Beach. This prime mixed-use lot offers extraordinary flexibility, allowing for the most intensive commercial and residential uses—making it one of the most versatile and valuable development sites on the island. Positioned directly behind a premier Gulf-front property (which is also available for sale), this location captures the best of both worlds: proximity to the beach with the added advantage of high visibility, accessibility, and development potential. Whether you envision luxury residences, boutique retail, hospitality, office space, or a signature mixed-use project, this site provides the perfect foundation for a landmark coastal development. Surrounded by world-class dining, marinas, shopping, and the vibrant Times Square district, this property sits in one of Southwest Florida’s most dynamic and high-demand beach communities—where foot traffic, tourism, and lifestyle converge. Opportunities of this scale and zoning flexibility, especially this close to the Gulf, are exceedingly rare. Unlock the full potential of this premier downtown beach opportunity today.

67 Miramar St, Fort Myers Beach
$3,500,000
2026002687 MLS ⋅ Crescent Beach BLDG.
Prime Mixed-Use Opportunity in Downtown District – Endless Development Potential Build Your Dream on the Gulf – Rare Fort Myers Beach Waterfront Opportunity – Welcome to one of the most coveted offerings on Fort Myers Beach—a stunning direct Gulf-front lot where endless sunsets, sugar-white sand, and panoramic water views set the stage for your ultimate coastal retreat. This is a rare chance to design and build a custom luxury residence in one of Southwest Florida’s most desirable beachfront locations. Wake up to the sound of waves, step directly onto the beach from your own backyard, and enjoy unobstructed views of the Gulf of Mexico from sunrise to sunset. Whether you envision a modern beachfront masterpiece or a classic coastal estate, this prime homesite offers the perfect canvas for a truly exceptional property. Located just minutes from world-class dining, shopping, marinas, and the vibrant Times Square district, this lot combines privacy, prestige, and prime location—making it ideal for both a personal dream home or a high-end investment. Opportunities like this are exceedingly rare. Now is the time to turn this Gulf-front dream into reality.

42 Avenue E, Fort Myers Beach
$2,750,000
2026001498 MLS ⋅ Island Shores BLDG.
Be one of the first to buy in Paradise Point on Fort Myers Beach. Located on the north end of the beach, close to Pink Shell Resort and just minutes to Time Square and Margaritaville. Easy access on and off the beach from this address. The previous Paradise Point Cottages were known for the fun and colorful cottages build in the 60's and 70's and now are being replaced with current code, elevated, hurricane resistant construction, unique and colorful custom beach houses. This is a Gulf front lot and is in the weekly rental area of the Island.

466 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$3,349,000
2026000177 MLS
Unbelievable multi-use Gulf side Property is available! Possibilities for building a small luxury boutique resort, condos or villas with commercial use on Estero Blvd. Prior structures had 15 units where you could step out onto the wide sandy beach and go to varied activities from this near-North-end-of-island location. This is the first time the property has been available for purchase in over half a century! Don't miss this developer's dream of building on this amazing property at a very attractive price. New survey is available on this property!

2100 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$3,349,000
2025026407 MLS ⋅ Polynesian Vacation Villas BLDG.
OPPORTUNITY OF A LIFETIME! This one-of-a-kind Gulfside property is located directly on Estero Blvd. next to Neptune and Diamondhead resorts, just one mile from the new Margaritaville and Time Square. First time available in half a century! Prior use was a mixed use development of 15 units: 13 residential vacation rental condo units, and two commercial office condo units. Potential future uses may include: Condos, Boutique resort, Mixture of Residential with Commercial use on Estero Blvd. Walking distance to all the beach activities, dining, shops and beach parks. Includes the entire parcel of land! A wonderful opportunity to build a new luxury development on this amazing site at an attractive new price! Don't miss out! A new survey is available on this property.

2096 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach
$2,543,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 226000175 MLS ⋅ Waterside At Bay Beach BLDG.
IMMEDIATE OCCUPANCY! One of London Bay's remaining residences in the newest and final tower in the gated community of Waterside at Bay Beach Lane. The wait is over for new construction on Fort Myers Beach/Estero Island, Florida's "Gold Coast". Enjoy this limited opportunity to be part of Grandview at Bay Beach, on the southern tip of Estero Island, just a stone's throw from Lover's Key, nestled between Fort Myers & Bonita Springs/Naples, where days begin with glorious sunrises, are spent leisurely shelling, beaching and boating, and end with amazing sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico. Grandview at Bay Beach is the ONLY new construction tower with WALKABILITY to the beach. Grandview is within walking distance to shopping, restaurants, a full-service marina, and in close proximity to RSW airport. This is truly a unique opportunity with limited residences available! Welcome to elevated waterfront living on Estero Island at Grandview. CONTACT US TODAY FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF REMAINING RESIDENCES!

4142 Bay Beach Ln Unit 806, Fort Myers Beach
$2,500,000
225084921 MLS ⋅ Beach Estates BLDG.
BAYFRONT, WEEKLY LOT! This exceptional property is a DREAM HOME LOCATION. It features an updated seawall, NEWER Honc Marine dock featuring 10k LB lift and 7k dual JETSKI LIFT. Featuring GEM remotes, it's ready for your vessels from day one. Simply bring your boat and start enjoying the waterfront lifestyle immediately. Perfectly positioned to build your custom island retreat, this weekly lot at the end of HIGH INCOME street offers the best of Fort Myers Beach living: direct bay access with quick routes to the Gulf, and a short walk to the beach, local restaurants, Times Square, and the bustling Margaritaville Resort. Picture spending your days boating and exploring the water, followed by evenings out on the island, then returning home to unwind with serene bay views and gently passing boat traffic from your future bayfront balconies. Owner has ready to permit plans for a 4BR 3500 sq ft or a 5BR 4500 sq ft build from R.G. Designs. Inclusion of plans is negotiable.

327 Fairweather Ln, Fort Myers Beach
$2,525,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 225081984 MLS ⋅ Waterside At Bay Beach BLDG.
IMMEDIATE OCCUPANCY! One of London Bay's remaining furnished residences in the last tower in the gated community of Waterside at Bay Beach Lane. The wait is over for new construction on Fort Myers Beach/Estero Island, Florida's "Gold Coast". Enjoy this limited opportunity to be part of Grandview at Bay Beach, on the southern tip of Estero Island, just a stone's throw from Lover's Key, nestled between Fort Myers & Bonita Springs/Naples, where days begin with glorious sunrises, are spent leisurely shelling, beaching and boating, and end with amazing sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico. Grandview at Bay Beach is the ONLY new construction tower with WALKABILITY to the beach. Grandview is within walking distance to shopping, restaurants, a full-service marina, and in close proximity to RSW airport. This is truly a unique opportunity with limited residences available! Welcome to elevated waterfront living on Estero Island at Grandview. CONTACT US TODAY FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF REMAINING RESIDENCES!

4142 Bay Beach Ln Unit 1002, Fort Myers Beach
Start Your Search